Mr. Guru Narayan,when we say that politicians are corrupt,does that mean that we should particularly pin point which particular politician is corrupt.That means that most of them are corrupt OR there are two type of corrupt politicians ---one who are caught and another who are not caught yet.
When we say that Govt. employees are careless--that is of course a generalised statement but certainly having truth in itself.
When we say Indians are not good at inventing --that is a generalised statement but certainly contains elements of truth in itself.
You state as if generalised statements have no truth or scientificality--dear me,only a certain intelligenc is needed to understand the meaning behind a general statement.
Whatsoever I have said about advocates is from experiences of my life---I am in contact with many advocates and none ever asks whether the clients are ethically wrong or right.Money not Ethics is the reason for taking up a case.
And now about Mr.Trinadha Rao--it is not necessary for him to declare the name of the wrong doer advocate--it is internet---every information should never be furnished over here.It depends upon the understanding of the writer how much information to publicize.So if Mr. Trinadha has not given the name of that particular advocate --it does not mean that what soever he has written is wrong.
Ofcourse I have critcised lawyers for advocating murderers,rapists,criminals etc but where I have said that if we can take some benefit from such people we should not take.A poisonous snake bite can kill us but that does not mean that we should not make medicines out their poison if we can.And by the way ,my questions/discussions are not meant for advocates only ,they are for the peopel of all walks of life.
About criticism---did not I appreciate Gandhi Ji (An Advocate) for accepting cases on ethical bases.Why could not you see that mine stand is depricating for the advocates who have no ethical values ? Why could not you see that my stand is appreciating for advocates who have soem ethical values ?
It is upto you that you are to be guided by the rules of Bar council( if they are as you have stated) or your conscience/ethical values(as I have stated).Mine statement may be illegal(as you have stated) but not illogical.
If a hard core rapist appears at your office and says that he has just raped and killed another 15 year girl and requests to you to fight his case and save him--please tell me how you serve the humanity by proving him innocent and saving him from the clutches of law.
Yes there is proverb--"we can wake up a person who is really sleeping, but not who pretends to be sleeping"
But who is slept is yet to be decided.