LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

sarvesh kanungo (n/a)     13 September 2016

Arbitration

when a legal agreement contains arbitration clause and how one can file a civil suit? 



Learning

 14 Replies


(Guest)

If the dispute is not the one covered under the arbitration clause then one may file a civil suit.

Regards,
Rit Arora
Advocate
7838737001

Simi Salooja (Legal Secretary)     13 September 2016

What about having Arbitration Clause in an appointment letter....

and the employee who should ideally approach a labour court... is opposed since there is a arbitration clause in the appointment letter

regards

 

Kumar Doab (FIN)     13 September 2016

@ Sarvesh,

Mr. Rit Arora has already suggested.

Kumar Doab (FIN)     13 September 2016

@ Simi,

Replied at;

https://www.lawyersclubindia.com/forum/Arbitration-for-industrial-dispute-between-an-employee-and-company-142070.asp

 

 


(Guest)

ID Act, 1947 is a special legislation and generally would override such agreement between parties. The law was passed having considered such situation. 


(Guest)

the employer may not be able to avoid liaility.

Simi Salooja (Legal Secretary)     13 September 2016

Thanks Rit ji...

So are you trying to say, even though in an appointment letter such a clause is mentioned... and the case is registered in Labour court..

Can the employee say that it was necessary to sign since he had to join the company, and the he had no other option at that point of time....

Will it favour the employee ?

Kumar Doab (FIN)     13 September 2016

The descripttion in the Act and illustration at the link is self explanatory. Both parties have agreed in writing. The matter in Industrial dispute should be covered as described in the sections and clauses in Act.

Meenakshi (Lawyer)     14 September 2016

Arbitration Clause in an appointment letter indicates that in event of any dispute arising out of the terms that form part and parcel of the appointment letter, such dispute can only be solved by appointmentof arbitrator. 

So for example- if there is a dispute like unfair labour practise, one has to file Complaint (ULP) before the Industrial Court.Only terms in the appointment letter if breached will have to be resolved by invoking arbitration i.e., appointing an Arbitrator.

 

Meenakshi (Lawyer)     14 September 2016

What is the case filed in Labour court? What is this employees Prayers?

Simi Salooja (Legal Secretary)     14 September 2016

Meenakshi ji...

Pls find the link below for your refrence

https://www.lawyersclubindia.com/forum/Working-as-a-Marketing-Manager-in-an-MNC-135357.asp

https://www.lawyersclubindia.com/forum/Arbitration-for-industrial-dispute-between-an-employee-and-company-142070.asp

Do you mean that if there are unfair trade practise that has been done, the employee should do a complaint? what is ULP?

and otherwise if there is a breach only then arbitration process has to be opted?

 

Awaiting your response.

Regards

Simi

 

Simi Salooja (Legal Secretary)     14 September 2016

The prayer is Reinstatement of job with back wages.

Meenakshi (Lawyer)     15 September 2016

Yes Simi.... This employee has filed a Unfair Labour Practise Complaint which he has rghtly done under the Industrial Dispute Act 1947.

 

They are two different issues... If the employee has removed employer without proper inquiry or on basis of no evidence, the employee can file COmplaint for reinstatement with back wages..

Arbitration can noot be invoked for breach of appointment letter.

Simi Salooja (Legal Secretary)     15 September 2016

Thanks Meenakshi ji...

Knowing this is a lot of relief... are you practising in bombay??

Regards

Simi


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register