LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Rajan Salvi (Lawyer)     12 March 2010

Desperate litigant.

Todays DNA.

 

 

 

A judge announced in the Bombay High Court today that he had received a call from a former client seeking to influence the case he was hearing.

 

 

Justice P B Majmudar, part of a division bench with Justice RV More, was hearing a dispute between the Ruia Group and Goyal Gas Limited (GGL) over the control of Bombay Oxygen Company Ltd. The call, seeking an order in favour of GGL, had come from Ahmedabad, he said.

 

 

He said he is still thinking whether or not he will pass an order and will inform those concerned on Thursday.

 

 

“Such things disturb us. Nobody understands the plight of a judge,” Justice Majmudar said. “Somebody must have told them that the order is likely to be passed today. Their machinery is more powerful than the CBI,” Justice Majmudar said.

 

 

The advocates for the two parties however urged the bench to go ahead and pass an order to send the right message.

 

“My conscience does not permit me to,” Justice Majmudar said.

 

 

He said “this tendency to treat court proceedings like any other revenue matter” should be curbed.

 

 

“Judges are kept away from mainstream society. We suffer because of that but we are happy to be suffering than being pressurised in this manner,” Justice Majmudar said.

 

 

Advocate Kamlesh Kharade, who represents GGL, said, “Nobody knows who has done it. But both parties will submit applications saying they have full faith in the court.”

 



Learning

 3 Replies

Kanaksinh P.Boda (Educationist/Lawyer)     12 March 2010

The Lawyers are killed. Judges are approached.Witnesses are managed.There is no place free from wrong doers. But the fact is that a common man has not lost his faith in judiciary, as is evident from the piling up of new cases regularly, because another lawyer takes over in place of killed one, justice is delivered in spite of witness turning hostile and Jusdges like Hob'ble Justice Majmudarj are keeping the system free from such bad elements.

hisifybird (retd)     13 March 2010

It may be true from a lawyer's view point. How do you say that common man hasn't lost faith in Judiciary ? Even if he loses faith, he has no other go. So he is simply managing with whatever is available

Kanaksinh P.Boda (Educationist/Lawyer)     13 March 2010

 The incident cited above is purely an acceptional one where it is has been openly discussed. God only knows of those which do not come to lime light. One can look at it as sight of ray in the darkness to which you are reffering. Againt it is purly a matter of one's perception to look at the glass filled half with water. This is a free country, after all. In 1400 a law was set forth in England that a man was allowed to beat his wife with a stick not thicker than his thumb and hence the proverb 'rule of thumb'. The opinion expressed is not in the category of rule of thumb.


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register