Advice needed from lawyers.

see the court would not direct this way to husband to live seperately and even if directed it cannot be enforced.

Wife can file RCR and seek restitution in a separate house away from the in-laws.  If she succeeds to prove the cruelty against her by the in-laws in matrimonial home, the court can give such a direction.  But the problem lies is - even though the court gives such a direction, it cannot be executable.  After waiting one year period, the husband will move divorce petition on the ground of non-execution of RCR decree.  He will get the beneift of his own wrong and it is permissible in mndian matrimonial law.

Thanks to all.

In this matter husband also wants to live away from his parrents to avoind quarrels. but his parrents are blakmailing him by commiting sucide if he leaves them and forcing him for divorce.so husband is not living with his wife from 1 year.And he is afraiding to give voice against of his parrents.so due to this weakness of the husband , parrents inlaws not behaved well With their DIL & in future also it will not be a piecefull life for the couple if wife will be ready to live with inlaws.

@ Mr. Nadeem

is it also consider under a cruelty , if wife wants to stay away from cruealty by inlaws? so what about the laws which had been made for women to protest against the cruelty

Can wife ask to get her matrimonial rights ( not the money)  in separate home away from inlaws due to cruelty of inlaws in her RCR .?

Wife has right of separate sesidence in lieu of her grievance against the her spouse.

i.e. Wife has right to live separately from husband.

But in lieu of her grievance against the her inlaws, she can't make husband as a party and demand the separate residence from him.

For that she has 'show that she is aggrieved by conduct of husband'.

So in an attempt to get the separate residence she risks her marriage by dragging husband to court.

the Laws are realy meaning less. If women uses the laws to protest against the cruelty it can broke her home. So she have only options either to live & tolerate with the cruealty till the stage of commiting sucide or divorce her husband even though she loves him.

She is waiting for her husband from 1 year. untill when she has to wait to get a rights of a wife from a husband?

one more thing. just today she mailed her husband & his sister to give her a compansation & alimony of 15 lack & make her life free from the uncertainty or live piecefully  in separate house away from his parents.

Her intension is not money. she wrote this may be for the greed of money his parents allow the couple to live separate.

Can this letter harmfull to her?