Ancestral property?

https://indianexpress.com/article/india/india-news-india/supreme-court-sets-2005-cut-off-on-women-right-to-ancestral-property/

Any news respected lawyers

Your bua's father is your grandfather!

My father buas's father is my great grandfather.

1. Here I am->Father->Father bua's->Father (He is my great grand father)

The judgment is clear, on ancestral property.

Go thru it.

You are asking about right of daughter in father's property i.e; Father's  Bua.

The succession opens on date of death.

So first assess daughter's right on date on death.

Then assess if property is ancestral and undevided (for Father's  Bua).

If it is self earned/acquired by father of daughter (i.e father of Father's  Bua) thn daughter has right in it.

.

The judgment is clear, on ancestral property.

Go thru it.

You are asking about right of daughter in father's property i.e; Father's  Bua.

The succession opens on date of death. 

Ans) In the year 1995 my great grandfather died and at that point of time there was no such law of daughter right over father property. It came in the year 2005 onwards.

So first assess daughter's right on date on death.

Ans) No at the time of death there was no such right at that time.

Then assess if property is ancestral and undevided (for Father's  Bua).

Ans) For ancestral I don't know whether it qualify it.

Ans) Yes It was undevided at that time and still its undivided today as well.

If it is self earned/acquired by father of daughter (i.e father of Father's  Bua) thn daughter has right in it.

Ans) Yes it is self earned/acquired by father of daughter

I have answered them, please guide 

Thanks,

I have case in concern with on the judgement (16/10/2015) given by Hon`ble apex court  by Hon`ble Justice Anil R Dave on Civil application  No.7217 of 2013 in the matter of Prakash v/s phulawati.

I want to know in the similar situation for my case

1. If there is a male  coparcener in place of PHULAWATI.

2. There was a Female  coparcener (died on 30.04.1975) in place of phulawati`s father(died in 1988 )

3. There is male in place of phulawati`s  Grandmother.

It means that No.1 is son (alive) and No.2 is Mother (died in 1975) and no.3 is Grandfather (demised)

If this position with what would be the final judgement ?

                > Can the Son have Right or Claim for the Agricultural  Land ?

I attached the Judgement of the Apex Court.

@ Deepak,

If proeprty is not partitioned and father and daughter are alive as on date narrtaed in judgment then  daughter has a share.

Rest discuss with a very able counsel specialzing in revenue,property, civil matters.

The issue was not with sons but daughters that was decided by apex court.

The sons have share in agriculture land as per personal law that applies to deceased owner.

we recently sold our ancestral and self earned property (house) and 9legal heirs

signed the registration deed to builder and stated that one of the eldest legal

heir took release deed in the year 1995(regd) Will their son/daughters can claim

share now. will the daughter of my brother has right to claim for equal right stating the

amount given very meagre whereas present value are more when sold just now?

Is the release deed given early should mention all legal heirs name?

p k srinivasan

@ P K Srinivasan,

It is felt that:

In ancestarl property eldest legal heir could have released his/her share.

Consent of (his) LR's was not obtained.

LR's have share.

Share is from property or actual proceeds collected by others (you and others)  by their explicit consent.

@ Deepak,

Property from mother's side is not ancestral.

Succession opens on date of death.

Agriculture is a state subject.