LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More


(Guest)

Calling wife as prostitute amounts to cruelty to wife

Calling wife as prostitute amounts to cruelty to wife

 
The appellant had also
caused injury to the reputation of the respondent by describing
her as prostitute and other objectionable words as stated earlier.
It is not expected that the husband would describe her wife as
prostitute and still, there would be good relationship between the
two. The injury to reputation is certainly an act of cruelty on
the part of the appellant.
Kolkata High Court (Appellete Side)
Malay Kr. Pakhira vs Papia Pakhira (Nee Mondal) on 8 September, 2009
Author: Bhaskar Bhattacharya
 
Citation AIR2010(NOC)225 (CAL)


Learning

 8 Replies

rajiv_lodha (zz)     22 September 2012

Well said, why call her prostitute............if she is not so! :-)

Nandha (NIL)     23 September 2012

if wife calls her husband as b*st*rd & son of a b*tch, will this be considered as cruelty? or, will it be considered as 'wear and tear' of family by the court?

 

a wife sent an sms to her husband calling him as  'illegitimate child' . Is it considered cruelty?

 

Tajobsindia (Senior Partner )     23 September 2012

@ Nandha,

1. No. Never, how cruel you are to even think of it!
2. It constitutes "on account of instigation of husband wife uttered those words in spur of the moment which she does not even mean it as found during her Examination in Chief". Donot believe me then challenge me I will produce here opposite Citations all the way from SC down to Trial Courts as THEIR Lordships interpretations.
3. Legislative intent is not to think at all a wife to be as prostitute where as there are many married prostitutes with established families in our society. That is the reason in most recent Census enumeration prostitutes upon several staged newsworthy agitations till late last year were included for the first time under “housewife” category as nations empirical GDP data!!!


(Guest)

 

Legislative intent is not to think at all a wife to be as prostitute where as there are many married prostitutes with established families in our society. That is the reason in most recent Census enumeration prostitutes upon several staged newsworthy agitations till late last year were included for the first time under “housewife” category as nations empirical GDP data!!!

 

 

 

V R SHROFF (Sr. ADVOCATE Bombay High Court Mob: 9892432152)     23 September 2012

By calling, you further spoil, u can't get anything. 

call decently by her name. 

Cruelty is not defined anywhere in Law, but callong her P  is ground for cruelty & Divorce.+ living separate & claim mtn, DV, etc. 

Tell Honest persona theif, and u create  one more theif .. Try to imrve the Society. 

why throw mud on Dirty face, U spoil your clean hand too. 

Nandha (NIL)     23 September 2012

@Tajobs,

 

'just on account of instigation the wife uttered the word' - if this is not accepted as cruelty, then in case a husband slaps a wife on account of instigation by wife, I understand that it will not amount to cruelty! correct me if i am wrong!

 

In 'Thirukkural', a tamil classic of couplets which expounds on various aspects of life, there is a couplet:

 

"In flesh by fire inflamed, nature may thoroughly heal the sore;

In soul by tongue inflamed, the ulcer healeth never more"

Tajobsindia (Senior Partner )     23 September 2012

@ Nandha,


The bare bottoms are only like this;


"When ever a husband does anything in his matrimony if their timing are going for good she will enjoy it even if he was found of spanking her bottoms and the moment her timings are undergoing bad monthly phase she is bound to take him to court for those enjoyed good times spanking now termed 'he used to daily slap me hazoor' and she will also have the tenacity to eat the cake too as afterall at the end it is ld. Judges discretion to protect current day's metro wife’s so called honor."


So that was straightforward translation of Tamil classics of common men’s requital before us. 


--------------------------

Oh BTW I did not attempt reply to your question “a wife sent an SMS to her husband calling him as 'illegitimate child' . Is it considered cruelty?

1. No it is not going to be proved cruelty to a husband. Infact she is asking a question lovingly is what it gets prime facie construed as.

2. Infact it now becomes matter under DEF
AMATION LAWS
for her Father In Law to challenge her for eyeing his manhood with a question!  

3. All that the Father In Law has to do now is to file a Defamation suit with paternity test result and call for Cell Phone records from Service Provider as Witness no. 1 and making her as first Respondent and his shy son as co-petitioner no. 2 of this sure shot Defamation Suit.

3. Father in law will succeed in his Defamation Suit and Certified Copy of his success story will now be used by son (husband to a lovely SMSing wife) to prove persuasive mental cruelty to HIS marriage.

Simple solution to your simple question before us. Hope I am done asked all these
J

stanley (Freedom)     24 September 2012

Originally posted by : Tajobsindia


@ Nandha,

The bare bottoms are only like this;

"When ever a husband does anything in his matrimony if their timing are going for good she will enjoy it even if he was found of spanking her bottoms and the moment her timings are undergoing bad monthly phase she is bound to take him to court for those enjoyed good times spanking now termed 'he used to daily slap me hazoor' and she will also have the tenacity to eat the cake too as afterall at the end it is ld. Judges discretion to protect current day's metro wife’s so called honor."So that was straightforward translation of Tamil classics of common men’s requital before us. 

and to add to it futher 

And coming back to indian classics of Kamasutra which the kings and queens of ancient time enjoyed and todays world relies on it for pleasure in the fast paced  world of modern times. As long as the honey moon is fine its okay but when a storm crops up  into rough weather  .Its going to be like i was  s*xually abused  etc  and a long list of allegations .



 

Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register