LCI Learning
Master the Art of Contract Drafting & Corporate Legal Work with Adv Navodit Mehra. Register Now!

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Naresh (In search of job)     25 July 2010

Can the divorce be revoked by higher courts?

Hi,

 

I have filed a divorce case on cruelty grounds(13(1)(i-a), and running since, july 2007 in family court. She, filed counter after 18 months (31 Dec' 2008) in which she also seeks divorce, and allegs that i'm impotent and I suppressed this fact so she claims damages for Rs. 50Lakh. I have no 498a, DV or any criminal cases, have only divorce and maintenance cases both civil. I have the following questions on this situation.

(1) In this situation, as soon as the trial completes, the divorce is issued either on cruelty grounds, if I win, since calling husband impotent is cruelty, so it is a proof of cruelty on the other hand divorce is issued on cruelty/impotency grounds, If I lose. But, in either case divorce is granted. My question, here is once the divorce is granted, is it challengeable in the upper court to revoke the divorce order on the ground that not enough maintenance or alimony is granted? Can you please enlighten me If my above thinking is correct?

(2) Though, I have filed for divorce in July'07, it has not even come to trial stage yet. The reason for delay is they didn't come to court for 18 months initially and later, judge retired arrival new judge took some months and there is court bandhs due to telangana issue. Now, is there a way to tell the court to decide the matter immediately as the delayed justice without the petitioner's mistake is also cruelty on the petitioner by the system?

(3) Is there a provision, to tell the court that since both parties need divorce, can it immediately be asked to deliver the interim orders to grant it and to decide the grounds a separate case or same case can be continued ?

(4) In my situation, what is the best/better approach according to the learned members?

 

-Naresh



 5 Replies

Guest (Guest)     25 July 2010

1.   Divorce decree cannot be challenged in appeal on the ground of inadequate maintenance.  For enhancing the maintenance, aggrieved party has got some other method instead of challenging the divorce.

2.  You can always ask the court to dispose your case early.  But the court, keeping in view of the arrears of the cases, may take its own decision.

3. Not possible.  First giving the divorce decree and later on deciding the ground is not permissible in law.

4.  In your case, as you are in hurry to get divorce, better sit with your wife and withdraw allegations and counter allegations and both move an application for Mutual Consent Divorce decree and get relief.

1 Like

Kiran (Consultant)     25 July 2010

In your case, both are agreeing for divore. Then why are you worrying about revoking of divorce in higher court. Instead of alleging false allegations on one and another, go for mutaula consent fo divorce. If your wife is putting too many conditions for Mutual consent or she is trying to extract money from you to agree for mutual consent, then let the present divorce case continue, as you will definitely get divorce becuase both of you want divorce.

N.K.Assumi (Advocate)     25 July 2010

Concur with the above responds.

Arup (UNEMPLOYED)     25 July 2010

mr kiran right. think of it .but as you bow down they may ask for higher maintenance.

most of the mutual divorce petition broken at this juncture.

Arup (UNEMPLOYED)     25 July 2010

higher court can alter the judgement and order.


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register