Counter foils of FIR and main FIR in the Court does not Tall

 which police station and which state ??

Same incidents happened in Kottaiyur village under Kolathur Police Station, Tamil Nadu. Though its not that necesary for the answer to the above question.

I don't know the relevance of the argument of the defence counsel. Is there any sanctity to the copy of FIR kept at Police Station for investigation purpose. When FIR books are scarce it is common for SHOs to keep the photostat copies of original FIR in Police Stations to save the forms.

 

If there is difference in the copy of FIR given to the accused and the original sent to court, the defence lawyer has some point in raising the allegation of forgery.

 

I wonder how the defence got the copy of FIR usually kept as part of the CD file with prosecutor for comaprison with the original FIR.

 

I have seen copies of FIR in some cases kept intact with the help of cellophane tapes as if laminated after transit through scores of offices.

See, it is something like my village case. An old woman bought a Nirma Soap, and after using for two months the lines on the Nirma soap disappeared, and when her neighbor brought the same Nirma soap from the town, she compared her Nirma Soap with her friend’s Nirma soap, and on discovering the difference, she went to town to the shop and complained that her Nirma soap is not the same Nirma soap and asked for change of her Nirma soap. The documents is same the authors of the documents is not disputed, only the difference in the edges of the counterfoils and the main body of the paper is not the same. Should the court allow such grounds to be taken as a duplicate documents?

 You have not made any great discovery. Manipulation of record in courts and government office is like the oldest profession.