Disownment

I disagree with the policeman's view and that advocate's view.  If you are living separately from your parents, then your wife does not have any right to demand that she should stay with your parents' in their home only.  She has got a right to stay with you, till divorce decree is granted.  The matrimonial home is where you live and not where your parents live.  But if you are playing game along with your parents to deprive her cohabitationn by simply pretending that you are living elsewhere and in fact you are really living with your parents, then the game changes.  If you are honest and living separately from your parents for any reason whatsoever including the reason that your wife will torment your old parents, she is not entitled to live with them.  Police does not have power.  If she approaches DV court, then you challenge her petition on the ground that you are living separately.

Thanks a lot for your help!!!

idea of disownment drama is comical.

what do you achieve out of it?

does this extinguish criminal liability? If yes then all ongoing 498a and 304b cases is quashed in single day by this experiment.

you are not disclosing proper facts of the case so no comprehensive advise is possible.

So I am not able to agree/disagree with view of expert above.

@ experts above.

The author has not described full facts.  We do no know to what extent the advise given to him will fit into his case. 

Unfortunate he is already suffering having hired an advocate who has fanciful ideas of "disownment" etc. So let him disclose facts and then seek sound advise.

The forum must be thankful to youfor having expressed gratitude in one of your threads.

But at the same time it is seen that

(i)                  You have multiple threads on the same issue.

(ii)                In any of the facts you have not conveyed full facts of the case

You are thereby :-

(1)    You are disclosing that you have no faith in the wisdom of the experts and repeatedly blogging same words.

(2)    Seems you rate experts as students of different section and set identical question paper for them.

(3)    Depriving the experts of the honour of giving correct and comprehensive advise.

(4)    Based on half faces you may get half baked advise which may not suit you and may even be counter productive and then you blame the experts.

You have following threads on the issue :-

(1)    https://www.lawyersclubindia.com/forum/details.asp?mod_id=111168&offset=1

(2)    https://www.lawyersclubindia.com/forum/details.asp?mod_id=111299&offset=1#.VFGcBGeO5G0

(3)    https://www.lawyersclubindia.com/forum/details.asp?mod_id=111298&offset=1#.VFGbpWeO5G0

(4)    https://www.lawyersclubindia.com/forum/details.asp?mod_id=111483&offset=1

(5)    https://www.lawyersclubindia.com/forum/Filing-case-restraining-from-entry-house-vs-disownment-111409.asp#.VFGbVmeO5G0