LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Shambasiv (n/a)     31 October 2008

Divorce and judicial separation

What is the difference between divorce and judicial separation?


Learning

 10 Replies

N.K.Assumi (Advocate)     31 October 2008

Simply put, divorce means the marriage is death and judicial seperation means the marriage is in coma.

1 Like

SANJAY DIXIT (Advocate)     31 October 2008

Yes Mr Assumi is abs. right about the real situation.


According to law after a divorce we may get remarry but after a jud. sep. we mayn't.

N.K.Assumi (Advocate)     01 November 2008

Dear SanjayJi, Thank you for taking the time to give your comment.

Shree. ( Advocate.)     01 November 2008

Dear  Sir,


   Great answer by Assumi Sir.


The procedures for divorce and legal separation are essentially the same. The actions are filed in the same way and proceed the same way through the court's calendar. And, the end result for both will be a final judgment which divides assets and debts, determines financial obligations between the spouses, and establishes placement and custody rights to the children.



However, a legal separation is different from a divorce. If you are legally separated, you cannot marry anyone else until the legal separation is converted to a divorce, and then you must wait six months after this is done. Also, if you are legally separated and you reconcile with your spouse, you can dismiss the legal separation and thus restore the marriage. In contrast, if you divorce, you will have to remarry your spouse. Also, in some circumstances, one spouse may be eligible for continuing health coverage from the other spouse's employer, even after a legal separation is granted. The same is not true with a divorce.


 

Akhilesh Maurya (Private legal practice)     01 November 2008

Judicial separation means severance  of  connection among the spouses by the order of the Court. But it should not be taken to mean 'divorce' for that also severs the connection of spouses. In Judicial separation the severance of connection is permanent and also affects the status and position of the spouses as husband and wife. Judicial separation thus is a step midway between subsistence of marriage and complete dissolution of marriage effected by divorce. Divorce is a remedy whereby the marriage is dissolved and the matrimonial tie is broken for ever.

RAKHI BUDHIRAJA ADVOCATE (LAWYER AT BUDHIRAJA & ASSOCIATES SUPREME COURT OF INDIA)     18 November 2008

I do agree with Mr. Akhilesh.

InSearchJustice   27 September 2010

Please suggest as per facts below:

1. Wife is Adulterous and confessed the same in written on plain paper before Panchayat.

2. She is willing to get divorced by mutual consent and separation period till date is just two months.

3. Kindly suggest what should be done to get divorce AS SOON AS POSSIBLE.?

4. Can a mutual consent divorce petition be filed mentioning Adultery facts and that too in a separation period of just two months.

Adv Archana Deshmukh (Practicing Advocate)     27 September 2010

For mutual consent divorce, the husband and wife should be living seperate for one year or more prior to the date of filing of petition.

smile imu (practising lawyer)     18 July 2011

Actually, judicial separation is executed by the order of court for specified time and here the marriage is still in existence; whereas the divorce is a permanant separation of marriage where marriage is not in present.

Anup Rawat (System officer)     07 January 2013

Many couples opt to file for legal separation for a variety of reasons, such as religious and cultural customs. Also, some married couples want to maintain joint health insurance, and some couples pursue a decree of judicial separation for tax reasons. Moreover, some couples may simply want to separate without officially terminating the marriage. Legal separation provides the married couple an opportunity to reconcile their differences. If the couple reconciles, there is no obligation tp obtain a new marriage license. However, the married couple will obtain a decree of judicial or legal separation, unless one spouse petitions for a decree of dissolution or divorce.


Grounds for judicial separation can be the same grounds to obtain a divorce, including adultery, domestic violence, desertion, neglect and more. Also, either spouse may pursue a no-fault divorce, whereby one spouse does not provide any specific reason to divorce the other spouse. All states allow married couples to obtain a no-fault divorce.

 

Reference Case Manish Tyagi Vs Deepak Kumar Decided on 10 Feb 2010.

 

 

 

 


 


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register