LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

maxx (pvt service)     06 September 2013

Does limitation act apply on dv cases

hi friends, i want to know that, in DV cases, where there is physical separation of more than 1 year ( in my case: 1 year and 2 months) and after that wife files 125 and after that DV case, does the act of limitation apply in these DV cases, as physical separation was there since last year, so there was no domestic relationship in existance while filing the DV case, so is the DV case valid?

secondly, if just before leaving the matrimonial house, wife gives a complaint letter to the police station and moves away to native place (FIR not filed by police, nor any NC or diary entry) only complaint copy acknowledged, then on the basis of that letter, will the DV case stand, even if separation happened immediately after that letter.

and, does the judgement of Justice Roshan Dalvi of bombay high court apply for the limitation period in DV cases?

please guide me friends, thank you each one...........................



Learning

 1 Replies

Tajobsindia (Senior Partner )     06 September 2013

1.    In my opinion Jstc. Dalvi’s Judgment is controversial as the facts in that case happened in overseas country and wife returned back to Indian soil and filed complaint which was dismissed by Justc Dalvi citing ‘limitation’. I would say the dismissal is wrong as the judgment is actually hit by bar of S. 188 CrPC and not limitation. It was for the parties to appeal in SC and clarify the position. I posted her Judgment here in LCI and gave my observations, dig from past postings and see for yourself why it is controversial.

2.    However I heard from fellow ld. brothers practicing in various trial Courts that few trial Courts have dismissed DV Complaint based on arguing this controversial Judgment so you can try your luck as I cannot quote those trial Court verdicts here who have dismissed DV based on Judgment of Jsct. Dalvi due to non-binding nature.

3.    Alternatively you may place facts and force plead for dismissal of DV Complaint case which alleged to have happened as ‘offence ~ violence’ word and phrase used in DV cannot be ‘continues’ if definition under IPC is put forward vehemently by a seasoned advocate.

[Last reply]

 


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register