Sudhir Kumar, Advocate (Advocate) 16 January 2014
Biswanath Roy (Advocate) 16 January 2014
Learned Mr.. kalaiselvan misunderstood my opinion to some extent which ought to be ignored as he might be similar to my son's age and experienced accordingly. Now let us have a look to the query afresh. The query of Mr. Dhanesh is " Is it O. K. to get engaged while Divorce case is still pending? " Here the queryst used a generic term " engaged " which may mean " an agreement to marry , the period after which the couple has agreed to marry but before they do so Decree for Divorce is to be obtained from the COURT. " Secondly,. it may mean a ": Betrothal" and thirdly it may mean consummation with an woman giving promise for marriage after obtaining Divorce order from the Court of Law. Be that whatever the querist actually meant to say if the fact of such engagement discloses before the Court it will obviously raise in the mind of the Judge that the complaint relating to divorce is a designed one for remarrying another girl and made out for malafide intention and it is an abuse of process of the court and in that event the Judge may dismiss the petition by invoking his inherent power and thus he may push the matter to appeal court for adjudication and the litigants shall face a lengthy proceeding.
Sudhir Kumar, Advocate (Advocate) 17 January 2014
Her cannot sit idle. That does not mean he can marry. Engagement in such situation though legally no hurdle but not advisable.
Biswanath Roy (Advocate) 17 January 2014
Writ of Mandamus is not applicable in this case. Aggrieved husband may file an application before the Family Court for early disposal of the case because unnecessary prolonging the case is ruining his life without any cogent and lawful reason more particularly when the wife is admittedly reluctant to live with the husband any more to discharge her marital and conjugal obligations. Save and except this no other measure will be fruitful.
Respected Mr.Biswanath Roy ji age is not a factor for any thing.what is truth what is material fact for any thinng.If your grandson tells some thing out of way how could we accept it . can you please define me what is marriage and what is engagement.My self plead this reply from Mr.Kalaiselvan Mr.sudhir ji abd Mr.B.ROy
Biswanath Roy (Advocate) 17 January 2014
I differ. In legal profession age is a factor in as much as it creates maturity of court experience and creates sharp acumen in legal jurisprudence which I transmitted to some of my juniors who according to my Bar statement became efficient Chief Justices of different High Courts in India.. Marriage according to legal parlance is " the legal union of a couple as husband and wife" whereas, the term "Engagement " according to legal parlance is " a contract or agreement involving mutual promises " or a " betrothal " but the engagement as it speaks to the query under reference is nothing but a " marriage per verba de futuro subsequente de copula "
Respected Mr.B.Roy ji Thank you for the reply.You know me during replies of other queries and i do have high respects and regards for you always.But the Engagement is not a Business Contract or Agreement where we could have SUBJECT TO ..Engagaement during Divorce pending clearly an evidence to prove the malafide intentions of the party and it has to be treated as illegal only.
Biswanath Roy (Advocate) 18 January 2014
Vide : GUARDIANS & WARDS ACT.
Ranee....... (NA) 19 January 2014
Biswanath Roy (Advocate) 19 January 2014
Child's custody pending Divorce SUIT SHALL BE DETERMINED BY THE COURT OF LAW following Guardians And Wards Act..