LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Ibrahim (Associate)     18 July 2013

False domestic violence case

Dear lawyers,

I am Syed belonging to muslim commuity.

Mywife has two residential address one at in my native, and one at a remote village which includes severe hill distance 260kms. My wife's parents brought the daughter to this address and get her married with me.I cared her like anything. During seventh month of pregnancy we did our customs (5-2-2012) and send her to the home in my native for delivery. she and her parents left uninformed to me and my parents to their another remote village address even without considering the hill track which is unsafe for the child in foetus. Since she left uninformed i stopped communication with her.Moreover I and my parents never visited the remote village or even invited by them atleast once.

She came back after 6 months ie 3 months after delivery period. We had a reconcillation with a mediator. I expresssed my desire to live if their parents doesnt involve in my family matters. The mediator postponed for 10 days for another round of talk. But again my wife and their parents went to the same village for 3 more moths without informing and came back again without informing. Again we had a reconcillation with another mediator mywife and her parents said they felt sorry and they had some work again in that village and will be back in 10 days. She stayed there for 2 months without informing and came back on 22- Feb - 2013.

Now they went to Jamath(Muslim mediation commitee) for mediation, again i expressed my desire to live with some written committments. During this course of the issue i heard about her past love affair with a guy. But after my marriage they dont have any contact to my knowledge and also he is working in a far away city and his native being the same remote viillage.So i was in dilemma state to take a decision and informed this to Jamath.They left to my decision.Again she went back to the remote village and filed a Domestic VIolence case with utter false allegations like forcible s*x, dowry demand, harassment etc..against me, parents and sisters who are married and staying away used to home on holidays to their parents house.

We got court notice travelled all the way along the hilll track and my parents alone appeared, since we three didnt receive the summon. My lawyer deined all the allegations since i have sufficient evidences. The magistrate  asked the remaining to appear on 12-Aug-2013.

The petitoner(mywife) have conducted, marriage and mediations here. But he filed a case in remote village to drag me, my old parens(aged 60 and 67) and sisters and their kids. The DV case filed without any protection officer report. Now my wife requesting me 16000 as interim maintenance and 24000 as maintanence statingi am a software engineer earnng 55000, and expressed her wish not to live asks their marriage expenses,streedan, some gold which snatched by me in the allegation. I hava adaughter more than one year old.

I issued talaq notice before received my summon copy. Please answer the following questions.

1) Can  i exclude my sisters as they are staying away?

2) Can i exclude women repondent based on Respondent defnition in dv act and also we being muslims.

2) Can i request for a protection officer report in my district?

3) Do i have to pay interim maintanence as it was her desertion? They are forcing for us for interim maintanence.

4) My lawyer is saying like we have to pay as it is protection for women act. Is it true?

5) Since i issued talaq, still the interim mantance request valid as Mahar is the only maintanence according to muslim shariat law.

Their family cheated us by hiding their ex love affair and spoile my 2 years of married life

I am ready to pay for my daughter's maintanence but not for her.

Please help me by providing your valuable suggestions how can i proceed firther as we are suffering a lot with mental pressure we are getting dragged here and there.

Regards

Syed



Learning

 4 Replies

Ibrahim (Associate)     19 July 2013

Can anyone please reply on this to overcome my current situation.

Nadeem Qureshi (Advocate/ nadeemqureshi1@gmail.com)     20 July 2013

Dear Querist

My opinion on you questions is mentioned below

 

1) Can  i exclude my sisters as they are staying away?

Opinion: yes you can, if you can proive it that she is living away from your family and there is no interfare in your family.

2) Can i exclude women repondent based on Respondent defnition in dv act and also we being muslims.

Opinion: No it can not be possible on this ground there is a judgement in which the court clearly held that the women family members or relatives can be respondents.

 

2) Can i request for a protection officer report in my district?

Opinion: you can file your objection on this point.

 

3) Do i have to pay interim maintanence as it was her desertion? They are forcing for us for interim maintanence.

Opinion: its depend on the case/allegation/ your earning and her source of income.

 

4) My lawyer is saying like we have to pay as it is protection for women act. Is it true?

It is not mandatory, if you prove that she left your company without any reasonable cause and there is no domestic violence has been caused to herand she ios an able body to maintain herself then the court will not pass any order for maintenance.

 

5) Since i issued talaq, still the interim mantance request valid as Mahar is the only maintanence according to muslim shariat law

Opinion: its dpend on the documents but she can not claim maintenance if she is able to maintain herself and Domestic violence will be applicable on you and not The Shariyat Act

 

Feel Free to Call

Ibrahim (Associate)     20 July 2013

Dear Lawyers,

Few more points to add.

1. Can i request for the case to transfer to mydistrict as everything including mediation happened in my district, she went to a remote village with 260 kms distance which i never visited once which is a hill track and filed case there without DV protection officer report with the ill motive of dragging my parents,kids,sisters.

2.What is the counter action if i can take if i prove the allegations as false.

3. Can i say the following reasons to stop interim maintanence as it was true. As she has asked for a huge interim.

Past affairs and cheated us.

Delay of 1.5 years in filing the case.

Without protection officer report., Desertion, Petitioner family rich and i have valid evidences to deny most allegations.

please tell me your valuable replies.

Regards

Syed

Sudhir Kumar, Advocate (Advocate)     22 July 2013

connect

https://www.lawyersclubindia.com/forum/Islamic-maintanence-and-dv-maintanence-84989.asp#.Ue1fg6zQzmk


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register