LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Hitesh Rughani (Proprietor)     01 January 2013

Law to be amended for rape cases

Suggestions

 

1.                  Definition of rape

2.                  First Information Report

3.                  Investigation

4.                  News

5.                  Courts

6.                  Bail

7.                  Punishments

8.                  Appeal

9.                  Mercy Petition

 

1.                  Definition of rape

Sexual interactions without the consent of other which involve physical torture, kidnapping, killing, murder, etc by one or more male to a female

 

Age group of female victim can be categorized from 0-16, 16-18, and above  18

 

2.                  First Information Report [FIR]

Upon request of the Victim, not below the rank of Senior Inspector and preferably in the presence of a female officer should lodge the FIR without asking any cross questions.

 

3.                  Investigation

Upon reporting FIR, the Senior Inspector shall appoint an Investigation Officer, not below the rank of three star or equivalent to investigate the case.

The Senior Inspector shall be accountable to lodge FIR upon failure, the Victim can file a direct case without medical reports and the Senior Inspector shall be equally responsible for the said cause i.e. the rape and punishment.

The Investigation Officer shall initiate and arrange the medical report at possible as early

The Investigation Officer [IO] shall arrest accuse or accuses for further investigation and shall produce before the Competent Court for remand and further investigation.

The State Government shall provide proper stores to keep the medical reports and evidences.

Investigation Officer shall be accountable to file a charge sheet within 15 days from the date of FIR, upon failing to file charge sheet, the Magistrate shall have to replace the Investigating Officer and have to punish the Investigation Officer for minimum 15 days simple imprisonment and or capital punishment and or suspension for minimum six months, the Magistrate has to follow the guidelines and rules and regulations.

 

4.                  News

No publicity through any media, especially no names and identity of the Victim and her family members should be revealed.

 

5.                  Courts

Fast Track Courts shall be established for speedy disposal of the cases, wherever possible, and if not possible, the Session Courts shall have the jurisdiction to try the cases.

Each case shall have time frame for speedy disposal, preferably two months,

No adjournment to be soughed and granted by and to the Advocates

Courts can be run in two or three shifts, depending upon the number of case and exigency of the case.

The Magistrate shall take oral or written statement of the Victim at his / her chamber or at hospital or at the Victim’s convenient place as the situation demands; the Magistrate shall not call the Victim in the Court Room.

The advocate of the culprit can examine the Victim in the chamber of the Magistrate in the presence of a NGO run for Female, advocate and relative of the Victim.  

 

6.                  Bail

No bail shall be granted till the final disposal of the case at trial level.

However, if the prosecutor fails to prove the charges, accuse shall be compensated by the State.

 

7.                  Punishments

Two options can be offered to the culprit upon disposal of the case.

Death Penalty along with half assets of the culprit to be transferred in favor of the Victim, if Victim lives or to her mother or other legal heirs;

Or

Culprit’s pennies shall be cut off, an official non removal permanent tattoo on his forehead to be affixed stating that “I am Rapist” with Government stamp, and regular monthly attendance to his nearest police station along with half assets of the culprit to be transferred in favor of the Victim, if Victim lives or to her mother or other legal heirs;

The culprit can choice any of the above punishment from above two options

If the rape done by an anti social elements or known criminals or a person against whom many complaints lodged, then in such case equal punishment is obligatory to the Senior Police Inspector of local police station.

8.                  Appeal

The culprit can prefer a Writ to the High Court and or a Special Leave Petition to the Supreme Court, no other Courts shall have jurisdiction to entertain an appeal.

There shall no provision of any appeal or revision with the High Court and the Supreme Court.

 

9.                  Mercy Petition

The provision for Mercy Petition to the President shall be abolished

Please comment your suggestions to send to Justice Verma at the earliest.



Learning

 2 Replies


(Guest)

@Thread starter,

It's really appreciable views and can be recommended to Verma committee,but i summarily reject/object the point you made under the heading "FIR"

.

There must be a provision of cross-examination as ignoring such precaution will give rise to number of false cases and for which the said victim(the person falsely accused) will suffer which may have ripple effect on his family too.



The duty of lodging FIR must be done with honesty by the police since it's not only the responsibility of Law makers to take care of everything including the executive operation. Citizens too fail in discharging their duty honestly(Feel it live in all public offices or public places,or around your society ).Failing to discharge his/her duty by a public servant who is a part of executive machinery of our country should be made punishable severely as well as departmental action should be taken as soon as possible for such lapses.



Also along with the victim name,the accused name should not be disclosed to media. Remember the accused family too suffers without any of their fault.



I also want to add to point number 6 that if  the prosecutor fails to prove the charge,there should be a through investigation by the police on the order of the court if the allegation was false, and if found false,she should be punished with imprisonment with either descripttion of a term not less than one year,and which may extend up to five years or with fine or with both. Such counter measures are very necessary to curb the misuse of such law.

 

Note-Since some selfish feminist organization want to use such events to feed their own interest, other laws relating to woman must not be touched so hurriedly. This recommendation should especially address the rape issues which is a menace to our society.

 

 

The definition of rape given in the section 376 of IPC is adequate and need not to be changed.

Penetration is an essential ingredients to constitute the offence of rape (As per IPC section 376 definition)but Where the essential elements lacks,such offence must not come in category of rape,rather come under the category of molestation of serious kind for which law-makers should make the punishment more stringent.

 

Hope to hear again from other members of LCI and you too.

I am open to clarify on certain issues(if need so arises)

 

 some words(Quotation) [may be ignored by readers]

© "Justice when done without microscopic inspection and without considering all dimensions spoils society and spoils everything falling within it's ambit and then in-justice come instead of justice come in."

 

Thanks,

Regards,

Hitesh Rughani (Proprietor)     02 January 2013

The recent incident of rape and brutal assault on a young woman in Delhi has shaken the conscience of the nation and has triggered a serious debate amongst jurists, civil society members and women’s groups about inadequacy of the present laws to protect the safety and dignity of women.

 

The Government has given anxious consideration to the need for reviewing the present laws so as to provide for speedier justice and enhanced punishment in cases of aggravated s*xual assault. For that purpose, a Committee has been constituted by the Union Government on 23.12.2012 under the Chairmanship of Justice (Retd.) Shri J.S. Verma, former Chief Justice of India. The other two Members are – (i) Justice Smt. Leila Seth, former Chief Justice of Himachal Pradesh High Court (ii) Shri Gopal Subramanian, former Solicitor General of India, former Chairman of Bar Council of India and eminent Jurist.

 

The Committee has to submit its Report within 30 days. The public in general and particularly the eminent jurists, legal professionals, NGOs, Women’s Groups and civil Society members are requested to share with this Committee their views, knowledge and experience suggesting possible amendments in the criminal laws and other relevant laws to provide for quicker investigation, prosecution and trial as also enhanced punishment for criminals accused of committing s*xual assault of extreme nature against women.

 

The suggestions can be sent by e-mail to justice.verma@nic.in or through fax at 011-23092675.

 

The suggestions should be sent by January 05, 2013 so as to enable the committee to complete its task and give its report with necessary recommendations within the available time.


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register