Our lawyer who was conducting partition case in Madras High Court on Flat fees basis, both in trial court and in appeal (OSA with two judges), after our OSA was allowed and the Judgment was delivered in our favor, after receiving flat fees for this OSA also in the beginning itself, suddenly asks extra fees exorbitantly at the rate of 10% of the benefits the shareholders will get, which works out to Rs 2 crores. He says if we agree for this exorbitant fee of Rs 2 Crores and also give him Rs.15 lacs now as interim payment only he will proceed and arrange to get the Judgment Order and preliminary Decree and further to arrange appointing Advocate Commissioner and to get final Decree.
The suit property value is about Rs 24 Crores and there are totally 6 shareholders (5 female shareholders on our side as Plaintiffs and 1 male shareholder on opposite side as Defendant) and each will have benefit of Rs 4 Crores. He has sent E mail to us demanding that each of us has to pay him 2% of the suit property value and further saying that it is 10% of each of our benefit. This itself is not correct and contradictory.
The value of the suit property is common for all the 6 shareholders consisting of all the 5 Plaintiffs and one Defendant and hence it can not be taken as a base for the calculation of the percentage for the fee payable by the Plaintiffs. His asking all 5 shareholders of us to pay 2% each on suit property value means actually we have to pay on the benefit of Defendant also which works out to even 2.4 Crores as his fee for proceeding the case. So his mail itself is confusing as he demands each of us (we five plaintiffs) to pay 2% of suit property value and he says it is 10% each of our share.
Is his demanding exorbitant fee after getting flat fee justifiable? Also is his demanding interim payment from this exorbitant fee justifiable?
The judgment was delivered 10 weeks back and still we have not been given Judgment Order and Preliminary Decree. Will it take so much time for the HC to prepare and give them? Is it not the responsibility of our Lawyer to follow up and get them from HC? Can he blackmail us that he will proceed only if we agree for paying this much fee and for paying now interim payment? If the situation remains like this in standstill what will happen to the judgment already delivered? Should all 5 of us will lose the shares due to any time limit for the operation of Decree?
How can we change our Lawyer to proceed further in our case if he refuses to give No Objection? In case of changing the Lawyer, will he indulge in any unfair practice against us so that we will be deprived of our benefits? The defendant may also go for appeal in SC, but our Lawyer says that it will be mostly dismissed on submission itself because the HC judgment is very strong. Can he do some moves in SC also against uf if appeal is allowed?
Kindly advise us to come out of this situation.