LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

S K (Executive)     23 October 2012

Need guidance/suggestions for divorce case

I need suggesstion so that I can help my friend in his divorce case.
One of my friend got married in year 2005. His wife was already having affair before marriage. She was forced by her parents to marry him, as the guy did not wanted any dowry and was educated and well settled.
She started quarreling with the guy and his family members and used to come back to her maternal home frequently. One day she ran away with her boyfriend from her maternal home and wrote on a stamp paper that she will be staying with her boyfriend henceforth and broke the relation with that guy.  The marriage was not registered one. Now its been 7 yrs, and he wants to marry and settle down, so now in this case how can he get the divorce ?

Any suggesstions would be appreciated. Thanks in advance.



Learning

 4 Replies

Adv.R.P.Chugh (Advocate/Legal Consultant (rpchughadvocatesupremecourt@hotmail.com))     23 October 2012

Your friend can file a case for dissolution of marriage on the ground of desertion as well as that specified in S.13(1)(vii) if the woman is not heard as being alive for 7 years and a missing report was promptly lodged after she ran away. In the latter it would be much easier to get. As to the process of going in for a divorce. Read my article : 

 

 

Divorce in India

This article explains all you need to know about getting a divorce in India.

 

Marriage as opposed to relations of blood, is one which we enter into by our own choice and not by virtue of our birth. Conceptually Marriage is both a Sacrament & a Contract.  It is a contract because it is based on offer and acceptance and is akin to an agreement to live together. Sacrament because of it’s religious ties.

As it is connected with the freedom of choice, sometimes we do make choices that do not turn out the way we would want them to be.

Divorce allows a person to break free from an onerous marital relationship. But since marriage is not merely a contract but a very important societal institution. The law has an interest in protecting marriage, and not allowing it to be severed only by choice and on ordinary wear and tear.  Since society in countries like ours takes special interest in protecting it – In our country to get a divorce one needs to prove certain grounds for eg : cruelty/adultery/desertion etc.  Known as matrimonial offences. (Crimes relating to marriage)

A happy marriage is a harbour in the tempest of life an unhappy marriage a tempest in the harbour of life, more and more people are realising the reality of their relationships, and accepting divorce as the rational choice to a better life necessary premised on better relationships. It is no more a taboo and especially so in urban cities.

 

Divorce by Mutual Consent is the easiest way to get a divorce, in this both parties work out their terms on which they agree to part ways- file petition in the court, which is finalised in 6 months. However there may be cases where the decision to part may not be a mutual one, and it is only one party who considers the union to be troublesome and worth getting rid off. Such situations lead to Divorce being contested.

 

Contested Divorce

In this regard we follow the fault based system of divorce. Divorce is granted only on proof of fault or guilty conduct of one party and innocence of the other. The most common ground for divorce is cruelty (Simply such conduct as to make it impossible for parties to live together – this includes mental or/and physical torture). Another common ground is adultery (s*xual intercourse outside wedlock) one instance of lapse of virtue can lead to divorce.

Divorces are also common on grounds of desertion (simply wilful abandonment of one spouse by the other without reasonable cause/excuse). Apart from this Conversion of religion/Unsoundness of mind/Renunciation of world are also grounds for divorce.

 

As per the law as it stands our legal system does not allow divorce to be granted on the ground of irretrievable breakdown of marriage or irreconcilable differences.(Known as no fault grounds). Call it impractical & absurd. To get a divorce one has to prove wrongdoing on the part of other spouse, and impeccable conduct of one’s own in order to win. Which is impossible sometimes. Legislature has taken note of this pragmatic reality and a bill on the same topic is pending in the Parliament, which would allow a person to seek divorce on ground of inherent incompatibility leading to breakdown of relationship.

 

PROCEDURE OF GETTING A CONTESTED DIVORCE

  • Ascertain the ground on which you want to seek divorce.
  • Collect evidences.
  • Consult a seasoned divorce lawyer and file a petition in the Family Court of your district.

 

HOW DOES YOUR CASE PROCEED ? AND HOW MUCH TIME DOES IT TAKE ONCE IT IS FILED IN THE COURT 

 

Petition is filed in the court with all the relevant evidences/documents. Person filing the petition is called ‘the petitioner’ and erring spouse responding is ‘the respondent’. (Remember to annex all documents on you rely with the petition itself – Videos/Audio Recordings/Photos are documents within the meaning of evidence act, and admissible in evidence, your’s spouse emails/chats/facebook/twitter updates are also admissible to prove depravity/infidelity or whatever !

 

After you file the petition in the court – erring spouse is summoned, if he/she turns up and enters appearance the matter is bi-parte, if the erring spouse prefers not to contest or come to the court, the matter is proceeded ex parte (in absence) and divorce granted if the matter is worthy of the same.

 

  • In case of bi-parte – the court normally would before seeking a reply from your spouse of the allegations levelled by you – would refer the parties to a mediation or conciliation, so that issues can be resolved amicably this way or the other. Whether leading to a reconciliation (living together) or an amicable divorce.

 

  • If the above fails, the erring spouse/respondent would file a Written Statement to your petition with the necessary documents (Normal time for filing a WS is 30 days (Max : 90 Days). Following which one can file a replication to further elaborate and explain.

 

  • Once that is done the court would frame issues – issues are questions that are to be decided by court at the time of final hearing. For eg : in a Divorce on the ground of adultery – the issues would be “Whether the respondent had s*xual intercourse with X during the subsistence of marriage with the petitioner” ? The answer to this question would decide the fate of divorce case. There may be more than one issue in case of multiple grounds. The entire divorce proceedings are premised at answering this question/issue.

 

  • After issues are framed – the court would ask petitioner to lead evidence, his own or/and his witnesses. This also is decided into three stages. First petitioner would lead his witness and examine him. Thereby putting the foundation of his case. (Called examination in chief) Thereafter the opposite party would cross examine the petitioner’s witness. (Called cross examination) Cross examination includes exposing the falsity of a witness’s deposition by putting leading questions, and contradicting the witness. Witness may either withstand the onslaught of questions – thereby retaining the confidence and reliance of the court, or he may stand discredited.

 

  • The Party calling the witness is further given an opportunity to fill the holes the opposite party’s advocate has busted into it and make the court believe in it’s witness.

 

The same process is repeated for each witness on either side. Once petitioner’s evidence is over, respondent leads his or her evidence. Please note petitioner/respondent/family members are all competent witnesses.

 

Once evidences are over. The Court would finally listen to arguments of either side on the case, and then proceed to decide the case.

 

On how the evidences are appreciated, to illustrate in a case based on cruelty the court would normally see whether on the totality of evidences led, is the conduct of respondent such as to make living together a practical impossibility ? Does it pose a great risk to physical or mental well being of the petitioner.

 

The Court’s formal order in the end is known as the ‘decree’. After this either party may appeal in the High Court and then finally the Supreme Court.

 

Normally the process in the Family Court would take anywhere between 2-3 years if contested vigorously. My experience has shown that parties normally lose patience somewhere in between and agree to part ways amicably. Because litigation does not really pay for anybody but the lawyers ! and that is the reason I advise my clients to go in for this only when the mutual option is unquestionably foreclosed.

 

*The Author is a Supreme Court advocate specialising in Divorce & Family Law and can be reached at bharat.law06@gmail.com or 9810553252

Abhishek Roa (Placement officer)     24 October 2012

Hi can u suggest me for following case my one student want justice. Name of that girl I’m hiding she want divorce.

My question/summery of girl:-

  1. Now that girl is around age of 22-24 year but she gt marred on the age of 16 due to family pressure. (Is this marriage is legal according to law) if Answer is no then how our law can help that girl.
  2. As per discuss with girl she told me her story. According to her his husband hurt her in many ways for example: - for baby, using abuse word for her, etc.
  3. According to girl she is perfectly all right. There is defect in that guy sperm (hormones). But that guy is blaming to that girl that she have some problem.
  4. Girl want divorce I suggest her that this marriage is illegal. But that girl is afraid to tell anything about her illegal marriage Because she think that if she say anything about on this matter in court in front of judge her family gt trouble .judge punish her family.
  5. Girl want freedom she wants to study she wants to become something in her life. I also promise her that I help her I give education to her. But according to girl every thing is depend on her divorce.       

  Her case is file in Bhopal court. She wants justice she want divorce she want freedom.

Presently she is lived with her parents. Every day she is waiting for her freedom. She is not belonging to rich family. Can any advocate or judge is there in these worlds who help this girl. This girl want to save her family (I know her family members do wrong with that girl) but girl want to save them and also want justice  

 

  1. This girl wants justice.
  2. Girl wants divorce.
  3. She also want in the time of her justice judge never punish her family.

 

My question

I’m Abhishek Rao working in NGO above detail I mention is not full story of that girl. Please suggest me how she gt divorce, how she gt her freedom back, is there is any advocate or judge who help her. Mostly divorce cases running long time can u change this rule of word long time?  Can she gt justice is short time?  

S K (Executive)     24 October 2012

Thank you alot. My friend did not filed a missing complaint, as he did not wanted her in laws to suffer. Her wife wrote on stamp paper that she is leaving him and going to stay with the person she was having affair with, and since then till now she is staying with that person and also having kids from that person, now how shall he proceed ahead. 

rajiv_lodha (zz)     24 October 2012

Get divorce by proving her adultery. U may also put criminal case on her partner


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register