LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Mahadev   01 April 2017

Transfer case hc_wife false residence_my options

Respected Lawyers/Members,

1. My wife had filed a transfer petition in HC to transfer our divorce case from one place of the state to her place where her family wields considerable influence. She had mentioned false residence address of that place to get the case transferred which she also has been successful.

2. My lawyer is not giving me the certified copy and both side lawyers are ensuring the same does not get uploaded in HC website too. When we tried to go HC to get copy we were denied permission saying we need lawyer to make PASS and enter Court premises. Despite we requesting our lawyer several times to do it he is not doing it and now avoding phone calls too. This is being done so that we are not able to file appeal to SC if required.

3. Could you tell me whether without Certified copy i can still file appeal in SC, tell SC about all what is happening and request Judge to please order a copy of it.

4. I really do not want to fight the case where it has been transferred in case SC rejects my appeal as there is a risk to my/family life and her adviocates have started telling us that either we pay 80 lacs or they will ensure we are called to that Court so many times that we will yield to their demand. Could you please advise what is the way i can tell that Court that i don't want to fight this case and not be represented by any lawyer. 

5. If notice/summon is being sent by that Court to us whether i should receive it ? if i receive it and choose not to attend due to the above reasons what are the legal complications if any like in Criminal case they issue Warrant to arrest and take us there forcibly and make us attend the case forcibly.

Don't i have a right in a Civil case not to fight a case . I do understand it may go adverse against me but it's better than risking my family's life. So please advise me.



Learning

 4 Replies


(Guest)

Dear Mahadev,

 

I felt very bad after reading your query.  Your lawyer appears to have been compromised.  Without certified copy of order, you cant appeal in appelate court.  Have you considered complaining to the District Judge about all this.

 

You have not mentioned what other cases wife has filed on you. 

 

You can argue your case before a court of law, but not for your father or son, who have to engage a lawyer. As a power of attorney holder for someone, you may sign sale deeds and agreements on his behalf, but you cannot argue for him in a court of law unless specifically permitted. The Supreme Court has ruled that except for petitioner in person, no one other than advocates are permitted to argue cases on behalf of others. Even officials cannot argue a case in court on behalf of the company in which they are employed, it said.   "A natural person can, of course, appear in person and argue his own case personally but he cannot give a power of attorney to anyone other than a person who is enrolled as an advocate to appear on his behalf," ordered a bench of Justices Markandey Katju and Gyan Sudha Misra in an order last week. "To hold otherwise would be to defeat the provisions of the Advocates Act," the bench said ruling out an ailing person giving power of attorney to his son to argue a petition filed by him in a court. Even allowing a person to argue his case before a court is not a matter of right. "It is a discretion conferred by the Act on the court to permit anyone to appear in a particular case even though he is not enrolled as an advocate," it said. That said, you should be aware of certain difficulties that you may face. No doubt, you would be the master of the facts of your case. But, you should also have a working knowledge of law, procedures and to some extent, the court-craft. If you don’t know the procedural and legal nuances, you may lose on important points. The courts have become slave to their own procedures. These procedures are required to followed mechanically even if they may appear to be ridiculous or obsolete. And, there are too many of them. Courts won’t allow you to digress from the established procedures. Even for filing a petition, there is a set procedure which may differ from court to court. Just to give an example, in Supreme Court, each annexure has be certified as true copy on its last page; in Delhi High Court each annexure has to be certified as true copy on each page; and, in Central Administrative Tribunal, each annexure has to be certified as true copy on the first and last page. So, you must know what to do where, otherwise you’ll have to keep spending your time and energy in curing the defects of filing, etc. After all, time also has some value in terms of money. This is just one requirement, there are so many others in each court. You’ll have to learn these by trial and error. This is not to scare you, but to caution you of the difficulties. As it is said, practice makes a man perfect. By continuously practicing in a court, advocates acquire knowledge of the law and procedures in a court. If you want to fight your own case, you’ll have to learn the tricks of the game from square one and will have to master those skills quite fast, since you are learning at the cost of your own case. You should also be aware that many of the presiding officers in the courts (i.e., the judges) may not look at the party in person in a favourable way. This is because a party in person may take extra time and say many unnecessary things and may not know the law and procedure; so, many judges lose patience. At the same time, I have seen some good judges who give a sympathetic hearing to a party in person. So, it all depends. Thus, if you have an aptitude for law (and, more so, if you have a degree in law), go ahead and fight your own case in court, without engaging a lawyer. The law does not stop you from fighting your own case and you have every right to do so. It is only the lack of knowledge of law and procedure that may pose difficulties. One more option could perhaps be to fight your own case, but take guidance (about procedures and basic provisions of law) from some junior upcoming advocate who may not charge you much. If you want to appear as PARTY IN PERSON you can file a Petition u/s 302(2) CrPC, 1973  for Criminal Cases and U/O-3 , R-1, C.P.C ,1908  for Civil Cases. 

 

You answer my questions.  Lets see what can be done here.

 

Dr. Atul [9013898936] (Lawyer, Scholar)     02 April 2017

Another grand copy-paste job HH ... https://tilakmarg.com/answers/do-i-have-right-to-defend-my-own-case-in-court-without-lawyer ... and whatever else place you copy-pasted from. You know how I figured it to be so, lol? Because you refer to a 4.07.2011 order of Gyansudha Mishra and Markandey Katju, JJ. in Goa Antibiotics v. R. K. Chawla and refer to it as "ordered a bench of Justices Markandey Katju and Gyan Sudha Misra in an order last week" ... btw, both Judges retired in 2014 😁

1 Like

(Guest)
Originally posted by : Atul (public ID)
Another grand copy-paste job HH ... https://tilakmarg.com/answers/do-i-have-right-to-defend-my-own-case-in-court-without-lawyer ... and whatever else place you copy-pasted from. You know how I figured it to be so, lol? Because you refer to a 4.07.2011 order of Gyansudha Mishra and Markandey Katju, JJ. in Goa Antibiotics v. R. K. Chawla and refer to it as "ordered a bench of Justices Markandey Katju and Gyan Sudha Misra in an order last week" ... btw, both Judges retired in 2014 😁

Abe ye.. tu ghonchu ka ghonchu hi rahega.  you dont know value of time.  Atleast you could have suggested something or other.  That also you did not do. Shame.😁 (copy paste smiley)

 


(Guest)
I like the response by Helping Hand. Very honest, sincere and truthful. It is a tricky decision whether to represent ourselves or through an advocate. While we may not know the entire procedures, some advocates cheat, collude, or too busy to represent us in our best interests. In my own case, my advocate had all these qualities; a worst guy. I think best is to hire an advocate as advisor but to represent ourselves. At least we have only ourselves to blame if something screws up!
1 Like

Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register