LCI Learning
Master the Basics of Legal Drafting in All Courts. Register Now!

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Pawan (Service)     04 December 2010

Using residential aprt. Flat for opening a montessori school

Hi

We 10 flat owners purchased flat from promoter one year back in the residential apartment as per municipal plan. Now the person who given the land to promoter for joint development of property started a Montessori school in the ground floor flat of building ( 5 flat allotted to landowner by promoter including ground floor flat as part of agreement ) .We have filed a case against the owner of land at District judge ( Jr. Div) for injunction by making municipality and promoter also as secondary defendant stating that the landowner is opening a commercial activity and using the common passages of residential building. The court has passed the status quo order on both the parties. The ex-landowner has got the trade license from municipality after court order to run the school and taken one or two admissions also. In reply to our case filed against him he wrongly mentioned that he has got a valid license from municipality and the flat owners including me are fighting with him and stopping him in running his school. He also mentioned that the flat owners should ask the association ( we have not yet formed any association as building is not yet handed over by promoter) to take the required steps instead of arguing him individually. He also got the time extended for hearing by filing a request.

At one side our case is going on but the landowner has started a fresh case against the building association (there is no association in place right now) and request the court that association members are asking for hefty and illegal maintenance charges and as I am not agreeing to association members they are forcing the children and guardian not to enter the school premises and creating disturbances.

I need following advice. a) Can landowner is eligible to file a case against association when a case is already been filed against him by the separate flat owner. At one place the landowner is requesting the court that flat owners should come through association and on the other side he is filing a case against association.

b) Can we apply to municipality that as per the sanction plan it is residential building and a case is going on against the landowner. So please cancel the license which has been issued when court order was in place.

c) Can landowner use the common passage without the approval of flat owners if association is not yet formed?

Any other advice if you think can help me in this issue is very much appreciated.

With rgds/ Pawan

 

 

 

 

 

 



 2 Replies

Kanaksinh P.Boda (Educationist/Lawyer)     04 December 2010

We have some what equal problem in our CHS and at all AGM, the owner of school assures that he will shift soon but is not giving any thing in writing. This is goind on for last five years and now he is trying to threaten the MC members that he will implicate them in cases of misappropriation of fund etc. People are scared to proceed against him as he is financially strong and creat nuisance for sure. However, as we are sailing in the same boad, we are also eagerly looking forward for comments of experts in this forum. Thank you  Pawan for bringing this issue.

Nu.Delhi.Law.Fora. (Advocate-on-Record Supreme Court of India)     04 December 2010

Dear Querist,

 

Attn: Mr. Pawan

 

It appears that you have build up a good case in your favour except the fact that you are not taking steps to bring out all these facts/allegations in your suit as it is developing. Please do so. You may apply under RTI to municipality for obtaining the sanction plan, if any, and also seek info as to applicable regulation/master plan whether the said place is purely residential or allowed for mixed land use. As regards use of the common passage by landowner for school purpose without the approval of flat owners, you may ask for relief in your own case by moving appropriate application. However, it is proper to instruct your lawyer handling your suit and act according to his/her advice.


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register