LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Others Judgments and Orders

What is cruelty in one case may not amount to cruelty in other case

 30 June 2020

The Apex Court while deliberating upon the concept of mental cruelty, examined a catena of cases observed that there cannot be any exhaustive definition of mental cruelty. “What is cruelty in one case may not amount to cruelty in other case.” Hence, ..

Posted in Others |   736 hits

What is the distinction between punitive and preventive detention

 30 June 2020

Article 22 deals with preventive detention and all laws passed under it or any action taken must be in conformity to the article. Article 21 also lays down restrictions on the power of preventive detention. TheSupreme Court in Maneka Gandhi. v. Union..

Posted in Others |   2294 hits

Proof of motive or intention to be cruel is not necessary if conduct otherwise is held to be cruel

 30 June 2020

The High Court while deliberating upon various judgments under the English and Indian law on the point of insanity, ruled that the defence of insanity is not available against cruelty in most matrimonial cases. Even if the offending spouse is not cap..

Posted in Others |   2525 hits

Power of the President to dismiss a state government is not absolute

 30 June 2020

The verdict of the Supreme Court concluded that the power of the President to dismiss a State government is not absolute. Further, the President should exercise the power only after his proclamation is approved by both Houses of Parliament. Until the..

Posted in Others |   1208 hits

Whether the transfer was violative of Article 14 and Article 16 of the Constitution of India

 30 June 2020

The court held that the promotion of petitioner as Chief Secretary was only in an acting or officiating capacity and not in a substantive capacity.It was held that the addition of the post in the Indian Administrative Service Cadre of Tamil Nadu Stat..

Posted in Others |   878 hits

Case filed against activist Rehana Fathima for posting a social media video of her kids painting her semi clad

 29 June 2020

The activist on Friday moved the Kerala High Court seeking anticipatory bail and has alleged that the complaint against her was because of religious and political rivalry and also added that her actions were part of the freedom of an individual. ..

Posted in Others |   804 hits

Whether a person who is not a Malayali Brahmin may be appointed as a temple priest in a Siva temple in Kerala

 27 June 2020

Upon hearing the parties to the case, the Court held that, any person who has vivid knowledge about the vedas and all other sacred documents and sufficient experience can become a priest. Further caste/community cannot be a criterion to decide his e..

Posted in Others 1 comments |   2515 hits

Appeal was allowed, and the court agreed to accept defense in the appeal stage

 27 June 2020

The court observed that right to life also includes the right to livelihood. “The sweep of the right to life conferred by Art. 21 is wide and far-reaching... That, which alone makes it possible to live, leave aside what makes life liveable, must be d..

Posted in Others |   1164 hits

Right to life does not include Right to die

 27 June 2020

The five-judge Constitutional Bench had held that “Right to Life” under Article 21 of Indian Constitution does not include the “Right to Die” or “right to be killed”. ..

Posted in Others |   1257 hits

Can a person be imprisoned on the ground that he did not discharge his contractual liability

 26 June 2020

The Court held that the International Law that the remedy for breach of International Law can’t be found in Municipal Courts. The reason behind this is that for enforceability of international law it must first take the form of Municipal Law. It was ..

Posted in Others |   4843 hits

The Habeas Corpus Case

 26 June 2020

The court by a majority of 4 to 1 held that in light of the presidential, no person has the right to make an application under Article 226 of the constitution in superior court for habeas corpus or any other order that contest the lawfulness of an ar..

Posted in Others |   1099 hits

Collateral agreement with the object of wagering cannot be declared to be void

 26 June 2020

In the present case, the parties had no intention to take delivery of the goods but were only dealing with price differences such that they mutually intended the transaction to be of wagering nature. Although wagers are void u/s 30 of ICA but cannot ..

Posted in Others |   828 hits

Gift deed set aside as it lacked the free consent of the executor

 26 June 2020

Where a fiduciary or quasi fiduciary relationship has been established, the burden of sustaining the transaction is set upon the party which is going to benefit from it to show that the transaction was of an unobjectionable nature as per s111 of the ..

Posted in Others |   1535 hits

Validity of an age-old practice of not allowing women who range between 10 to 50 years into the temple of Lord Ayyappa in Sabarimala

 26 June 2020

Upon hearing the parties to the case, the Court held that, the exclusionary practice is violative of fundamental rights under Articles 14,15, 17 and 25. Further, the Court went on to say that, Exclusionary practices are contrary to constitutional mor..

Posted in Others |   607 hits

The Apex Court invalidated Sec.66A of the Information and Technology Act, 2000 in its entirety

 26 June 2020

The Court invalidated Section 66A of IT Act in its entirety as it violated the right to freedom of expression guaranteed under Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution of India...

Posted in Others 1 comments |   957 hits

Plaintiff entitled to claim the reward as the open offer was duly accepted

 25 June 2020

In the opinion of the court, the Plaintiff had substantially fulfilled the terms of the contract. There was an open offer to the whole world on behalf of the Defendant through the handbill and was also capable of getting an acceptance from any person..

Posted in Others |   5981 hits

Interpretation of Section 52(1)(I)

 25 June 2020

Section 52(1)(i) is the educational exception in the Copyright Act which permits reproduction of copyrighted works in the course of instruction. In the present case, the court held that photocopying qualifies as the reproduction of the work by a teac..

Posted in Others |   1234 hits

No copyright in ideas, plots or themes

 25 June 2020

It can be concluded from the present judgment that no protection is afforded to the ideas, plots or themes under the Copyright Act, 1957. Therefore, ideas, plots or themes are not a subject matter of copyright law...

Posted in Others |   5582 hits

Case Analysis of: State of Madras vs. Srimathi Champakam Dorairajan and Others

 25 June 2020

It was held that classification in the Communal G.O. is on the ground of religion, race and caste. The classification in the Communal G.O. is in abuse of the Constitution and it is a clear violation of the fundamental rights under article 29(2). It w..

Posted in Others |   4989 hits

Procedure established by law must fulfill fairness, reasonableness and justness

 24 June 2020

The Supreme Court said that Article 21 could be invoked only upon a complete deprivation and not upon restriction of movement. The SC said that word ‘law’ in Article 21 could not mean rules of natural justice. These rules were vague and ambiguous and..

Posted in Others |   894 hits