LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

puneet (puneet)     11 August 2014

125 crpc hingh maintenence awarded of rs 20000 pm

Please Advise on a very serious issue in 125 CRPC.

CASE POINTS

Allegations:  Demand of dowry,Demand of Money,Demand of Honda City Car,Transfer of Shop,Maltreatment,Beating ,Torture,Not provided food,Not allowed to wear gold articles and use dowry articles at matrimonial home. Husband is big businessman and having lacks of Rs of Income monthly, have own big business.

Doccuments provide to support their allegation during Trial Current account bank statement wiothut the owner's name and of selcted time period of 3-4 months having trasactions of approx 18 lacks. 2 web site print out to show that husband is a owner of firm and having lacks of rs of income. Few recipts of physiotheraphy of rs 15000 pm on child's foot. (this content is out of pleeding in compalint) Sumbmitted one certificate from physiotherapist that child needs physiotheraphy. there is no prescripttion from the doctter on file.

One PW has tendered his affidavit but did not come for cross examination and they closed their evidence.

We have placed firms owner real doccuments such as orginal VAT certificate,bank certificate of prop. ship,bank statements along with the prop. name,other doccuments to show the husband is not owner of firm and dont have any share in it. Submitted one declaration on Firms letter head that prop. of firm is ready to transfer all the assetes and liablities including bank account in the complainent's name but she refused to accept the same during her cross examination that doccuments is on file as Exibit. She also admitted that she maintains certiain accounts of firm and visited firm several times and also admitted worker of firm during her cross examination. Submitted husbands salary doccuments that he is getting only Rs.5000 from firm as a supervisor. She also admitted during her cross examination that she is an income tax assesse we submitted 4 ITR but she only admitted 1 ITR of rs 1,26,000 and denyed other 3 on saying that she might have submitted the same but dont remember now. We have submitted during argumants the original attasted by Income Tax Officer all 4 returns that these are genuine. She admitted in cross that she was working as lectarer prior to her marriage. Sumbits that husband has no source of income his father is depositing interim maintenace of rs 15000 in court. submitt around 25-30 photgraphs of diff occasion and hill stations she admitted mostly and are on file as exhibit few she denied again submitted in arguments as a email exhanged between the complainent and husband she already admitted her e-mail address those photographs are exchanged in between both. also submitted few emails exchanged in between both about a holiday package booking, submiited affidavit and corss of PW 2 owner of firm. other relevent material which came out from the complaint and her father's cross examintaion on many allegations. 2 RTI on the issue of physiotheraphy is not required in treatment. other medical books on the child physiotheraphy which clearly says that no physiotherpy is required and some news paper cutting on the same issue which says no physiotherpy is required. two email of different ocasions in which complainet is demanding for gold rings.

they have not submitted any proof of income of husband ,husband is not an income tax assesse.

Judge bypass our all the evidence and give maintence of rs 20000 on the ground that child is not well and expensive treatment is going on and she is justifyed in living seprately and awrded Rs.10000 each.  Please advise what should i  DO and please provide few valued apex court case laws regarding my case.

 



Learning

 7 Replies

puneet (puneet)     11 August 2014


Attached File : 99590831 img 0660.jpg, 99590831 img 0661.jpg, 99590831 img 0662.jpg downloaded: 237 times

puneet (puneet)     11 August 2014

order page 4-6


Attached File : 99590831 img 0663.jpg, 99590831 img 0664.jpg, 99590831 img 0665.jpg downloaded: 213 times

Prasad (Systems Engineer)     12 August 2014

Hi Puneet,

A judge's order is not always final till one of the party have a valid appeal to make.

One of our respected members ESIS has posted 10 Best Way to reduce/Dismiss Maintenace/Interim Maintenance Amount.

Please read here and act accordingly. 

https://everysuffererisasaviour.blogspot.in/2014/01/10-best-way-to-reducedismiss.html

Thank you ESIS. 

puneet (puneet)     12 August 2014

but Mr.Prasad it is very difficult situation if i will not get stay on order then it will be very difficult to plead our case in revision


(Guest)

You have accepted dowry to the tune of 35 lakhs and what not.


This is a purely business relationship.


There appears to be no human feelings.


Now its the time for you to cough up money.


You have a girl child out of marriage.  Your aim should be to lead a happy marital life for the sake of the kid that you have produced.  In all this you and your family have time and again asked for more dowry, car etc.


Whatever it might be, now its the time for you to pay money.  10000 alimony is not a big amount when there is a kid out of the wedlock.


But as you have asked advice, its my duty to give one, file change in circumstance petition in HC after a period of 1 year from the date of order.


Shame on you, that you accepted dowry.

puneet (puneet)     12 August 2014

Mr.Helping  hand read it once again we have not recived any dowry or worth of 35 lacks it is only allegation in the complaint How can you say such a rude words when you dont know the reality i have already put facts above.         


(Guest)

You recieved dowry or not is immeterial. Making false Allegations will amount to mental cruelty, inturn you can use them for your divorce case.  Your aim should be to get out of this mess. For that you have only two choice, one is to get MCD, another is to fight all cases till they get over. Reality is you and your wife are in court and will face endless litigation. Its better to pay off lumpsum money to your wife and ask her MCD. Otherwise you both will lose lots of years in court without gaining anything. As far as the alimony part goes, you will need to pay up all arrears till date and then you can file change in circumstance application citing new reasons at the end of one year from date of order of alimony and continue doing so year after year. Hope sanity of mind prevails in both of you.


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  


Related Threads


Loading