Can a registered Will be challenged in the Indian Court?

Coverage of this Article

Fraud

-A document made by any person that obliges any other person to work in part or in full for consideration or without any consideration will not be allowed to sustain. 

Coercion

-Any person committing an act of violence against any such person from whom any obligations have to be fulfilled or any task has to be compelling without the consent of his/her is known as coercion.

Undue Influence

-Undue influence is to use the influence by way of position of power or for any reason of emotional connection wherein the decision is taken is not based on sound mind or informed reason. 

Wills having suspicious nature

-When any person creates a Will wherein any of the content(s) of the Will is vague or has no meaning as to substance, then such Will can be challenged, whereas if there exist two Wills wherein one is vague and other supplements other at the same time then such Will can be challenged, and such objection will be allowed by law.

Error in executing the Will

-As any person who wishes to execute a Will, he has to perform some functions in creating Will and then some legal compliance to validate the Will and create a Will that has the support of law and is recognised in the eye of law. If there are errors in the execution of the “Will”, then such a Will can be challenged in the court of law.

Error in the substance of Intention

-As discussed above, the Will can now be fairly understood as the Testator’s demand/desire/order for dealing with his property after death. 

Incapacitate for Testamentary

-There are certain pre-conditions required by any person who creates the Will that is mandatory for him/her to comply, without which anything done in such process of creation will be termed as null and void.

Following are certain conditions for creating a Will

A person should be in the clear conscious to understand the terms and content of the Will and its effect with regards to the execution.

-A Will is a very important aspect of a person’s life as it decides who will inherit all the hard-earned money once the person is dead.

In India, the concept of Will has its deep-rooted origin for a very long time; its importance grows with the feeling of transferring family wealth and business from one generation to another with ease.

A Will is a declaration by way of an established instrument wherein a person disposes of their property which shall take effect after their death and which to its primary nature is ambulatory and revocable during that person’s life. The Will was mainly recognised because of its ambulatory characteristics as it was a distinguishable feature of the disposition from the normal deed. According to the statute, a will is the aggregate of man’s testamentary intention so far as their manifested duly executed.

A will is a written document wherein a person states the procedure of devolution of his/her property and manifest his/her desire as to what and how a lifetime worth of assets will be dealt with after his/her death. A person who creates the Will is known as the ‘Testator’, and the person for whom the Will is executed is known as the “executor”, and the property disposed of in the Will is known as the subject matter of the Will.

In India, as the registration of the Will is concerned, the Indian Registration Act, 1908 deals with the provision that has to be complied with, and as per the provision of the Indian Registration Act, 1908, there exists no provision for making the registration of the Will compulsory , because if the Act makes such document to be registered compulsorily that will attract some adverse consequences in many aspects of its practice in India. The registration of the Will in India is optional and at the peril of the parties creating a Will. The contrary opinions have been formed on the matter of registration of Will. It is always advisable by the legislature that a Will if made, should be registered. The Will has not necessarily been too registered by the testator or the creator of the Will, but any person who is an executor of the Will can write the Will after the testator's death. A Will can be kept with any person by himself (testator) or by any executor with the registrar wherein the Will was registered; the Will of the person can be deposited in the seal covered with the testator's name attached with the statement of nature of the document.

There are several legal considerations to creating a Will.The registered Will is a registered document/deed that can be challenged in the court of law for many reasons mentioned in this article below.

1. Fraud

A document made by any person that obliges any other person to work in part or in full for consideration or without any consideration will not be allowed to sustain. Such document will not be attributed any validity or legality in the eye of law. A registered document is though earned, a presumption that it is free from any malice or by any way illegal; according to the same understanding, it is interrelated that the registered Will is free from any fraud. The person who challenges the Will in the court of law on the reason that it was created by fraud the burden is upon him to prove the fraud in the registered document or registered Will.

2. Coercion

Any person committing an act of violence against any such person from whom any obligations have to be fulfilled or any task has to be compelling without the consent of his/her is known as coercion. An act of coercion is illegal in the eyes of the law. If the reregistered Will is created by an act of coercion, it will be deemed unlawful, but such a person claiming the Will to be illegal has to prove that the Will is unlawful in this context.

3. Undue Influence

Undue influence is to use the influence by way of position of power or for any reason of emotional connection wherein the decision is taken is not based on sound mind or informed reason. Such a factor plays a major role in deciding whether any document registered under such influence has any morality or, for that purpose, any legality. The registered Will for any purpose, if made by the undue influence of any family member or by any member of the testator, can be challenged in the court of law if proven by the substantial evidence on this behalf.

4. Wills having suspicious nature

Various aspects prove the legality of the Will in the court of law, whereas the nature of Will also falls prey to being challenged if the Will is not created in complete accordance with these aspects. Following are various aspects if found, or deficient such Will could be challenged in the court of law:

• When any person creates a Will wherein any of the content(s) of the Will is vague or has no meaning as to substance, then such Will can be challenged, whereas if there exist two Wills wherein one is vague and other supplements other at the same time then such Will can be challenged, and such objection will be allowed by law.
• There exists a fault with regards to the stamp required by the Testator for registration of Will, and if such Will is not duly stamped but still registered, it can be challenged.
• If the thumb impression is required on the Will or not duly made or if there are more thumbprints though required by the law, such impression creates confusion among the signatories on the Will, such confusion on a Will can also be challenged in the court of law.
•  If by the creation of Will there exists a disposition of property or devolution of any rights in the property but such disposition or devolution is made in favour of any person who is not remotely connected or there exists no connection to substantiate Will’s validity, then such Will can be challenged in the court of law.
• The Will has been executed at any place, but while registration, the date, time, and place has to be mentioned on the Will, but if at all the site of the execution on the Will is not mentioned, then such Will can be challenged in the court of law. E.g., If a person has executed a Will in a hospital, but the executor or any person concerned failed to mention this on a Will, then there can be a question raised on the validity of the Will in the court of law.

5. Error in executing the Will

As any person who wishes to execute a Will, he has to perform some functions in creating Will and then some legal compliance to validate the Will and create a Will that has the support of law and is recognised in the eye of law. If there are errors in the execution of the “Will”, then such a Will can be challenged in the court of law.

6. Error in the substance of Intention

As discussed above, the Will can now be fairly understood as the Testator’s demand/desire/order for dealing with his property after death. Any person while making a Will maintains a clear and transparent content as to the wish of the Testator, but such intention of the testator should be made clear, and the content of the Will should be concise and unambiguous, but if by any interpretation of the Will there seems so that the provision of any clause in the Will seems ambiguous or contrary to the intention of the testator then such clause or any Will to that extent can be challenged in the court of law.

7. Incapacitate for Testamentary

There are certain pre-conditions required by any person who creates the Will that is mandatory for him/her to comply, without which anything done in such process of creation will be termed as null and void.

Following are certain conditions for creating a Will

1. A person should be in the clear conscious to understand the terms and content of the Will and its effect with regards to the execution.
2. A person should be told, or he/she should understand the extent of his/her property he/she wishes to dispose of or his/her rights he/she wishes to devolve to someone.
3. A person willing to create a Will shall be able to comprehend and appreciate the claims to which he/she ought to give effect in terms of execution.
4. A person should be sound, and every decision taken by him/her should be in clear mind to its application when it’s brought in effect as to substance.
5. No person should be allowed to make a decision or create a Will at the time of any phase of paralysis of sound thinking or informed decision making.
6. If a person has a situation of mental disorder in intervals, a Will can only be created when the person is of sound mind.
7. A person should comply with all the requirements of section 10 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 for a valid establishment of Will.

A Will is a very important aspect of a person’s life as it decides who will inherit all the hard-earned money once the person is dead. Therefore, in a country like India, it becomes very important that if a person finds a Will formed to be unsatisfactory, then he/she has the right to challenge the registered Will in the court to make sure there is no misconduct happening. The registered Will can be challenged for all the reasons mentioned above, and the procedure to be followed has been discussed in the article.