My client has lost the original dishonoured cheque just before filing the complaint. Can a complaint u/s.138 N.I. Act be filed with Missing Certificate issued by the police? Any judicial precedents please.
My client has lost the original dishonoured cheque just before filing the complaint. Can a complaint u/s.138 N.I. Act be filed with Missing Certificate issued by the police? Any judicial precedents please.
Raj Kumar Makkad (Adv P & H High Court Chandigarh) 07 January 2010
No complaint under section 138 NI Act can be filed without having original cheque but the suit for recovery can be filed with the supporting evidence of bank, police, accounts etc.
saurav (private practice) 07 January 2010
you still can file the complaint stating loss of the cheque and could tender preliminary evadence in form of affidavit narrating the story and can exhibit photocopy of the same along with memo issued by bank or u can get a bank certificate from the bank , postal reciepts and acknowledgements can be exhibited in evidence
Daksh (Student) 08 January 2010
Dear All,
I endorse the view of Mr.Saurav. There is no bar as such - the problem about taking the cognizance of the offence can be satisfied/corelated with the police report. Out of the curiocity I just want to point out that apart from S 138 NI Act as a standard practice you might be adding Section 420 of IPC and depending upon the reaction of the presiding officer you can proceed accordingly. I would suggest to research thoroughly for case law on this aspect.
Best regards
Daksh
Smita_L01042008 (student) 08 January 2010
i agree with Mr. Saurav
B.N.Rajamohamed (advocate / commissioner of oaths) 08 January 2010
Sir,
You can file the complaint first by producing the xerox copy of the cheque if any. or you file it by submitting the statement of accounts from the drawee bank pertaining to the concerned numbered cheque . Then yoiu can examine the bank officer of the drawee bank in evidence for complainant.
Adinath@Avinash Patil (advocate) 13 January 2010
YOU CAN FILE COMPLAINT U/S 138 OF N.I. ACT BY PRODUCING PHOTO COPY OF CHEQUE SUPPORTED BY AFFIDAVIT AND ORIGINAL CHEQUE RETURN MEMO. YOU CAN ALSO LEAD EVIDENCE CONCENED BANK BY AFFIDAVIT .