LCI Learning
Master the Art of Contract Drafting & Corporate Legal Work with Adv Navodit Mehra. Register Now!

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Mallik Karra (Done with AIBE)     16 February 2011

separate law for deserted NRI brides

“Needed: separate law for deserted NRI brides”

 

 

NEW DELHI: Strongly advocating separate legislation to address matrimonial discord, maintenance, settlement of property and custody of children, experts on Tuesday said the new law could serve as a comprehensive ready reference for foreign courts deciding on litigation between non-resident Indians and Indian citizens.

 

Highlighting the inadequacies of the existing legislation, the experts, speaking at a national seminar here on “Issues Relating to NRI Marriages,” said certain provisions were needed to address international protocol and jurisdiction issues.

They favoured mandatory registration of marriages, simplification of the procedure for quick issuance of visa by foreign missions in India to any deserted woman to enable her to contest the proceedings filed by her NRI/Person of Indian Origin (PIO) husband in a foreign land.

Introduction of a system of cross-checking or consent when an NRI/PIO wants to cancel sponsorship of his spouse's visa, barring ex parte divorce by foreign courts in the case of marriages solemnised in India as per Indian law, and not permitting deportation of the woman in order to let her contest the case were some of the other points of discussion, made at the seminar organised by the National Commission for Women (NCW) and the Ministry of Overseas Indian Affairs.

Advocate Ranjit Malhotra suggested that as part of consular protection obligations, foreign embassies, missions and consulates in India mandatorily furnish all relevant data of the erring NRI spouses, who are habitually resident and domiciled in foreign countries.

Some sort of practice directions or a protocol could well be framed by the Ministry of External Affairs, in conjunction with the Ministry of Overseas Indian Affairs and the Ministry of Women and Child Development, to direct embassies and foreign missions to provide meaningful consular assistance to abandoned NRI brides.

Basant K. Gupta, Additional Secretary, Ministry of External Affairs, drew attention to the sensitivity of the issue, and suggested bringing about a common ground between the two parties and signing of a pre-nuptial affidavit that marriages performed in India would come under the jurisdiction of Indian courts.

D.K. Sikri, Union Secretary, Ministry of Women and Child Development, said the issue of NRI marriages could be included in the 12th Five-Year Plan.

The NCW demanded that it be recognised as an authorised body to directly file applications before foreign courts and foreign missions on behalf of aggrieved women.

Minister for Women and Child Health Krishna Tirath said the government was doing all it could to address issues of NRI marriages.

Girija Vyas, NCW Chairperson, said the NRI Cell, started in the Commission in 2009, had received 515 complaints of desertion. Of the 415 women from India, 68 were from Delhi, 42 from Uttar Pradesh, 36 from Haryana, 27 each from Punjab and Maharashtra, 25 from Gujarat, 24 from Andhra Pradesh, and 13 each from West Bengal and Tamil Nadu. The remaining were from other countries.



 3 Replies

N.K.Assumi (Advocate)     16 February 2011

They should form an Association under the Society Registrtion Act., to fight out collectively. Even in Nagaland, there are many deserted brides by their foreign husbnd, and it is time to think bout this mtter seriouly.

Guest (Guest)     16 February 2011

Thanks Mr. Mallik Karra for this beautiful information.

But after going through this material, I am as clueless as as the wives deserted by NRI / PIO husbands about amelioration of the miseries of these unfortunate women, whose parents sold the entire ancestral properties to give fat dowries to the families of NRI /PIOs with a fond hope that their daughers will "Raj Karengi" in the foreign lands, but their daughters are left out in parental home after a brief spell of honeymoon and husbands ran away to the distant foreign lands without leaving a clue about their residential and official contacts.  The CJM,ACJM, MM courts are also as much confused as any other  person that how to serve the notices / summons to the deserting husband, against whom cases are filed.  The Ministry of Home Affairs, The Minstry of External Affairs give different circulars with different procedures to be adopted in such cases and those circulars help in creating more confusion than solve the matter.

Roshani Bji and Ambikaji also posted news items on the subject in the last few days.

Now, I came to know  by this news article that National Commission for Women would export the eminent advocates to foreign lands to protect those unfortunate women's rights who are trapped in matrimonial disputes in foreign courts.  So far so good.  There would be budget allocation for this purpose and the chosen few advocates and their advisors, who curry with the persons in power, will be having foreign jaunts at regular intervals.  The NCW was given a responsibility to make a comprehensive bill on this subject and we do not see any progress in this direction, even though it is long pending.  The Ministry of Home Affairs and External Affairs can simplify the procedure to bring the matrimonial offenders before the Indian Courts, by having bi-lateral agreements with USA, UK, Canada, Australia, Gulf Countries, where maximum number of NRIs are livings.  That the Government in power does not do nor the NCW exert its influence in this direction.  It is so much to expect from NCW, which has failed us to effectively fight against "honour killings" to serve the certainn political and caste interests.

It is the time for the Govt. as well as Apex Court to ask the Law Commission of India to study the subject comprehensively and prepare a draft bill for sending it to Parliament to make an Act on war basis, so that innocent and wronged spouses stuck in the native land get their matrimonial rights enforced.     

PARVEEN DEEPAK ARYA (ADVOCATE)     22 June 2011

Sir

I have a problem to be resolved . An engineer gets work permit in U.S.A. His wife is also software engineer . He get her wife resigned and take her to U.S.A. In the meantime his wife come to know about his affairs with some other girl . She Objects . He threatens her but the family feud continued . On one fine morning he takes all his gold ornaments , jewellary and bring her back to India . Here he steals the Passport of his wife and himself leave for U.S.A. . Afterwards the sister of the husband provide passport to the wife . In the meantime the husband li8ving in the State of Texas files divorce . my quarries are

1 Whether the non resident wife can be divorced by the husband living in an other country

2  whether the inconsistency of divorce rules in both the countries is applicable ?

3  whether this grant of divorce will be valid ?  


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register