LCI Learning
Master the Art of Contract Drafting & Corporate Legal Work with Adv Navodit Mehra. Register Now!

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Judgments and Orders by Nihal Thareja

avatarView Full Profile

Witnesses can be cross-examined as to previous statements in writing

 29 July 2020

The court observed that the words "to contradict him" appearing in s. 145 of the Evidence Act must carry the same meaning as the words "to contradict such witness" in s. 162 of the Code. Further, the court laid down that the witnesses can be cross-ex..

Posted in Others |   1593 hits

Appeal dismissed based on oral evidence without corroboration of witnesses

 29 July 2020

The court found no substance in the contentions of the appellant whereby it was pleaded that evidence cannot be accepted without having a corroboration of independent witnesses. The court accepted the sole testimony of the victim who was shot with a ..

Posted in Others 1 comments |   1514 hits

Husband is liable to pay maintenance even after the expiry of iddat period

 28 July 2020

The court held that the view expressed by the First Revisional Court that no Muslim woman can maintain a petition under Section 125 Cr.P.C. is unsustainable. Conclusions in the view of a statement alleging utterance of the word ‘Talaq’ thrice is not ..

Posted in Family Law |   2498 hits

Liability of a husband to maintain his wife is not confined to the iddat period

 28 July 2020

The court upheld the validity of the Act while reiterating the principles laid down under Shah Bano case that the husband’s liability to maintain his wife is not confined and doesn’t end with the iddat period. A distinction has to be made between ‘pr..

Posted in Family Law |   1421 hits

Section 132 only protects the accused in the case where he is compelled to answer a question and not where the accused voluntarily answers

 23 July 2020

As per the dissenting opinion of Justice Birchwood, section 132 of the Indian Evidence Act read with section 14 of the Indian Oaths’ Act, compels a witness to answer criminating questions and he is protected by the proviso to section 132 from crimina..

Posted in Constitutional Law |   1810 hits

A dying declaration not in the question-answer form is admissible under s.32 of the Indian Evidence Act

 23 July 2020

The Supreme Court examined the question on the admissibility of the three dying declarations of Smt. Uma Devi and observed that the principle on which the dying declarations are admitted in evidence is indicated in legal maxim – “Nemo moriturus praes..

Posted in Others |   907 hits

Deed was executed out of love and affection not subject to undue influence

 02 July 2020

The Supreme Court allowed the appeal and held that there was no presumption of undue influence being used in this case. In case it was to be proved, the burden lies on the person who is in a position of power to influence the executor. The deed was e..

Posted in Others |   2077 hits

Deed declared invalid on based on the question of authenticity

 02 July 2020

The Supreme Court set aside the order of the High Court which was passed in favour of the Respondents and upheld the decision of the trial court. It was held that the current facts and circumstances raised grave concern over the genuineness over the ..

Posted in Taxation |   4582 hits

Constitutional requirements have to be satisfied while issuing an order for phone tapping

 30 June 2020

The Supreme Court while affirming the infringement of Right to Privacy via phone tapping laid down several guidelines for the exercise of the Executive’s surveillance. It was laid down that the home secretary of the Union government or the State gove..

Posted in Constitutional Law |   699 hits

Power of the President to dismiss a state government is not absolute

 30 June 2020

The verdict of the Supreme Court concluded that the power of the President to dismiss a State government is not absolute. Further, the President should exercise the power only after his proclamation is approved by both Houses of Parliament. Until the..

Posted in Others |   1258 hits

Collateral agreement with the object of wagering cannot be declared to be void

 26 June 2020

In the present case, the parties had no intention to take delivery of the goods but were only dealing with price differences such that they mutually intended the transaction to be of wagering nature. Although wagers are void u/s 30 of ICA but cannot ..

Posted in Others |   873 hits

Gift deed set aside as it lacked the free consent of the executor

 26 June 2020

Where a fiduciary or quasi fiduciary relationship has been established, the burden of sustaining the transaction is set upon the party which is going to benefit from it to show that the transaction was of an unobjectionable nature as per s111 of the ..

Posted in Others |   1648 hits

Plaintiff entitled to claim the reward as the open offer was duly accepted

 25 June 2020

In the opinion of the court, the Plaintiff had substantially fulfilled the terms of the contract. There was an open offer to the whole world on behalf of the Defendant through the handbill and was also capable of getting an acceptance from any person..

Posted in Others |   6153 hits

Petition dismissed, Ratlam Court had the jurisdiction to entertain the suit

 25 June 2020

The Court held that the Contracts over the telephone are treated similar in principle to those contracted by the parties in the physical presence of one other. An oral offer is made and an oral acceptance is to be completed in both cases. It is essen..

Posted in Constitutional Law |   1617 hits

Union of India and Insurance Company not held liable as plaintiff failed to prove loss

 22 June 2020

The court held that the plea had been raised on the wrong impressions under Disabled Persons Act. The Indian railways stand not liable on the basis of contract which was admittedly made with a foreign railway. The burden of proving that the car was l..

Posted in Others |   700 hits

The obligations under the agreement are to be performed by parties

 22 June 2020

The court held that the contentions of the defendant do not appear to be correct in the facts of the present case. The contract in itself had indicated the terms in which the respective obligations were to be performed by the parties. The court provi..

Posted in Others |   1884 hits

The Poultry business was a joint venture and not the sole proprietary

 22 June 2020

The court held that the business was a joint venture and not the sole proprietary concern of the Appellant No. 1. There is no document in writing to prove partnership. Accounts had not been demanded by the plaintiffs or the defendant no. 3 for a long..

Posted in Others |   739 hits

Violation of principles of natural justice by BCCI Commissioner under Rule 38

 19 June 2020

Rule 38 of BCCI Rules was examined and it was held that it only stipulated the creation of a committee and not a Commissioner to inquire concerning the procedure for conducting proceedings in case of misconduct, hence the appointment of commissioner ..

Posted in Others |   696 hits

Mortgage debt found to be for valuable consideration. not hit by s9A(10)(ii)(b)

 19 June 2020

Following the order of the High court, it was held that the family transferred the mortgage interest in trust to the charity for valuable consideration within the meaning of s. 9-A(10)(ii)(b) of the Act and the mortgage deed was not liable to be scal..

Posted in Others |   2612 hits

Plaintiff did not move any consideration under section 25 to make the agreement valid

 19 June 2020

The court rejected the contentions of the plaintiff. It was held that the shops were constructed at the desire of the collector and additionally there moved no consideration from the plaintiff under s25 of the act in order to consider it as a valid c..

Posted in Legal Documents |   2849 hits