Is the Madras High Court right in directing caste wise census? |
|
| Yes | 79 % |
 |
|
| No | 19 % |
|
|
|
| Cant Say | 2 % |
|
|
|
| _ | 0 % |
 |
|
| Total Votes Cast : 386 | |
| Submitted By - Prakash Yedhula | Read Comments |
| Posted by Davinder Khurana Ferozpur(Punj |
12/06/2010 09:30:13 |
| It promotes castism | |
| Posted by mahantesh shigli |
30/05/2010 19:53:23 |
| that leads to an armory in the hands of unscrupulous Indian politicians | |
| Posted by Suchitra. S |
27/05/2010 17:25:52 |
| When we cannot have Uniform Civil Code, it is better if we have cast wise census. At least it helps to know the rate of religious conversions.. :) | |
| Posted by shankar |
27/05/2010 11:02:36 |
| it is very easy to apply the various benefit schemes of the government to help the needy people | |
| Posted by puneet saxena |
26/05/2010 20:22:16 |
| it will the real economic condition of general caste and economically weaker section of general caste can ask reservation also.if everyone will ask for reservation then we can get rid of caste based reservation and as well as caste also | |
| Posted by Member (Account Deleted) |
26/05/2010 14:45:49 |
| definition of backwardness requires a fresh and unbiased thought free from all political motives. | |
| Posted by arun |
25/05/2010 15:34:17 |
| it should be effective | |
| Posted by Adv.Aiyer VLV |
24/05/2010 14:16:39 |
| Mr. Jasvinder Right! First Indians have to dissolve the difference in all these, which by itself confirms we do have them. Before that Government should stop mindless reservations at all levels and now we are talking quota in quota, religion wise(unwise!?) quota, quota in army. soon the so called minority can be majority in army | |
| Posted by Adv.Aiyer VLV |
24/05/2010 14:14:25 |
| Bravo Mr. Pramod. You are right | |
| Posted by Adv.Aiyer VLV |
24/05/2010 14:11:50 |
| Ms. Ruchi Judgement or census does not promote casteism. Government itself and Quota ruling already a law in India promotes casteism. HC only confirmed the position of Law as interpreted by SC and actions of government all along being crooked equality of law | |
| Posted by Pramod J. NIKALE |
24/05/2010 13:38:46 |
| Its is the landmark judgement of Hon'ble Madras High Court. this is because, it makes understand the social, financial, employement, educational status of the population. And thus will be in a better possition to understand the society and hence eradicate the poverty, illeteracy, social backwardness. By making caste wise census we will also be in a better possition to allocate funds for the needy, poor, illiterate people and thus make them come in main stream and also taste the fruits of the glowing Indias economy. further everyone must mention their real caste in the forms. this will ensure the prosperity of India in a better way. and once again I heartly thanks for the landmark judgement of Hon'ble Madras High Court. Pramod J Nikale, Advocate Mumbai High Court | |
| Posted by Ruchi Gupta |
24/05/2010 10:38:26 |
| IT PROMOTE THE CASTEISM WHICH IS NOT GOOD FOR INDIANS. | |
| Posted by Jasvinder Singh |
23/05/2010 21:34:18 |
| Let the Indians dissolve their castes,creed,religion and regionalism into oneness i.e. INDIAN. | |
| Posted by Punit Prahalad |
22/05/2010 17:00:47 |
| Do not promote caste-ism. | |
| Posted by Muneeswaran K |
22/05/2010 11:00:14 |
| Since most of the Govt's allocations are caste based it is correct | |
| Posted by P.K.Haridasan |
20/05/2010 22:58:49 |
| IT IS HIGH TIME TO THINK ABOUT A CASTE LESS SOCIETY. THIS WE CAN ACHIEVE IF WE HAVE GOT A WILL. NOTHING WRONG IN GIVING BENEFITS TO THE DESERVING,POOR, SOCIALLY BACKWARD CLASSES BUT IT SHOULD NOT BE A WEAPON IN THE HANDS OF CLEVER EXPLOITING PEOPLE. | |
| Posted by O. Mahalakshmi |
20/05/2010 20:00:57 |
| Why should we make census as per caste wise. I do not like it. | |
| Posted by vijaybhushan |
20/05/2010 16:08:16 |
| distribution of resourses and job appotunity in govt.sector is based on cast bases so why shy to adopt the census on cast bases. | |
| Posted by Adv.Aiyer VLV |
18/05/2010 10:36:48 |
| Hi There are many interesting comments in FB http://www.facebook.com/l.php?u=http%3A%2F%2Flawyersclubindia.com%2Fpoll%2Fdefault.asp&h=12ef8 regards | |
| Posted by Adv.Aiyer VLV |
17/05/2010 23:52:42 |
| I think the poll is more for judgement on judgement of HC than on whether caste based census is proper to conduct. I obey their judgement and hold it in high esteem Mr. Rao There are various divisions in every country. it is not true to say that we alone have castes. Historians have cast us caste, but they are not chaste. | |
| Posted by V.G.Rao Advocate |
17/05/2010 20:05:51 |
| For any thing or for every thing in India, why should we divide human beings in the name of caste which does not exists in the other countries, this is legally an uncivilized practice in India, becoz of which India is loosing so many intellectuals in all fields of govt and as well as in private bodies as reservation system prevailing in our country? In my opinion only the persons who are economically back word should given opportunity only for education and not for employment, after education the recruiting process in any field must be through merits only irrespective of any caste, the courts should not encourage caste systems in India,instead they should eradicate the caste system with its roots, courts should order the govt to issue an ordinance to the general public from hence forth that the new future generation shall not name their kith and kins with the names which will reflect caste in their names such as Ravinder "Reddy", Ashis "Agarwal", Nandu "Yadav" Rama "Naidu" Sunita "Soni" ramesh "goud" etc, and further in the application forms there shall not be column of caste for admission in schools, colleges,then only Our nation develops in to a super power nation like America, and becoz of caste system only India is burning every day, whether people accept it or not but it is true. the people of one sect is blaming the sect of other people due to this cast systems, Is it not? | |
| Posted by Adv.Aiyer VLV |
17/05/2010 17:24:26 |
| Ms. Uma, The very same mirages you have been quoting is keeping castes in our society and keeping the social justice far away., you must have heard of SC notice to kerala Govt for giving quota to brahmin economically backward. is there not hypocrisy and politics running and ruining castes? | |
| Posted by Uma parameswaran |
17/05/2010 15:26:52 |
| I am not supporting the caste base census.But for getting present social , economical and educational position of the reserved people, it is necessary for taking further steps. | |
| Posted by vijay |
17/05/2010 13:23:47 |
| in the year of 1931 such type of census held. Time and again the issue is raised that we have no figures. It creats confusion. There is nothing wrong in such cesus. Why we shy in census. Ultimately it is a socio economic problem. If we want its permanent solution, it is necessary. vh kanara | |
| Posted by vijay |
17/05/2010 13:23:01 |
| in the year of 1931 such type of census held. Time and again the issue is raised that we have no figures. It creats confusion. There is nothing wrong in such cesus. Why we shy in census. Ultimately it is a socio economic problem. If we want its permanent solution, it is necessary. vh kanara | |
| Posted by Adv.Aiyer VLV |
16/05/2010 06:05:20 |
| Mr. Prakash I am sure you would have waited for the period of appeal to SC to post this if not or if appeal filed already and pending, this is contemptuous! | |
| Posted by Adv.Aiyer VLV |
15/05/2010 16:42:53 |
| What the heck? we have caste based application forms we have caste based quota - sub quota we have caste based parties we have caste politics we cast votes on caste based politics why make hypocratic fuss on caste-sensus, we have no sense use | |
© 2024 LAWyersclubindia.com. Let us grow stronger by mutual exchange of knowledge.
