LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Kumar (accountant)     06 June 2014

Can i accept landlords settlement

Sir,

For the past 30 years we are running a retail business in the ground floor of a three-storied building (which is a flat system building, each floor have separate document, servey no, door no.) Few years back our current landlord bought all the three floors. After completing one year from purchase date he filled fair rent case and eviction case on us in small causes court.

He got the case in his favor within one year of time. Then we appealed against the case and able to pull it for 4 years, now it’s sounds like he is going to get it in his favor just like he did in the previous case. (Even though we have lot of proofs in our favor, his layer knows how to deal with the court and the judge). 

My lawyer says we can approach high court and drag the case for 3 years and not more than that. 

Now my landlord is trying for a settlement, (as we are keen in proceed the case in high court and also because of his lawyer is getting too greedy) i.e. he is willing to give the property for a higher price, but we are not ready to buy it as the price is too much, now he is negotiating for lease it for 3 or 4 years for 15 lakhs, 

1)      Now my question is shall we accept the offer of 15 lakhs as it is not a big burden to us. But after 4 years if he wishes not to renew the agreement, can he eject us by simple procedures or he has to start from the beginning i.e. filing case in small causes court.

2)       Is 4 years is ok?

3)       If he sell the property what will happen to the lease agreement? Will the new buyer honor it?

4)       If the new buyer wants to vacate us does he have to start from the beginning i.e. filing case in small causes court? 

5)       He bought the property through property loan; does this have any bad effect on the lease agreement?

I am asking these questions as I am not able to judge the landlord’s trust worthiness and his current financial position. He bought the property through property loan.  It sounds like he is in need of money that’s why he is negotiating for leasing the property.   We are also interested in it as we are not able to drag the case too much.  But need some guidance before proceeding further as we don’t want to risk our hard earned money. All the negotiations are taking place outside the court.



Learning

 3 Replies

T. Kalaiselvan, Advocate (Advocate)     07 June 2014

To your questions:

)      Now my question is shall we accept the offer of 15 lakhs as it is not a big burden to us. But after 4 years if he wishes not to renew the agreement, can he eject us by simple procedures or he has to start from the beginning i.e. filing case in small causes court.

Accepting the offer for 15 lakhs is your choice based on the prevailing circumstances, if it favorable, you can go ahead or else, decide.   For eviction he has to follow due process of law.  I think your lawyer has not taken up your cse properly hence you have lost it in the lower court.

2)       Is 4 years is ok?   For what?

 

3)       If he sell the property what will happen to the lease agreement? Will the new buyer honor it?  The new buyer has to honor the lease agreement because you have got no concern with the new buyer, so your owner should have taken your consent before selling otherwise, you can remain a tenant and the new buyer has to again follow due process of law.

4)       If the new buyer wants to vacate us does he have to start from the beginning i.e. filing case in small causes court?  Yes, same due process of law.

5)       He bought the property through property loan; does this have any bad effect on the lease agreement?

That is not your concern, let him face problems that way.

1 Like

Kumar (accountant)     08 June 2014

Sir,

Thanks a lot for your reply. 4 years is landlords' preferred lease agreement period. I am asking whether it's ok or should I ask him to stretch it for 5, 6 years.

All we want is to stay as long as possible; we are not able to drag the case in the small court as it was the first ever case faced and not knowing good lawyers. Now we gained some knowledge about court procedures and current lawyer is far better than the previous one.

So now instead of going to high court (can’t drag the case more than 3 years as told by our current lawyer, IF THIS IS NOT TRUE PLEASE REPLY), If the current landlord sell the property or he withdraw the cases (i.e. if he lease it to us), it will be beneficial to us as we can stay without any legal worries, but just want to make sure that the lease amount will be remain secure even when the property is sold to other person. 

Biswanath Roy (Advocate)     09 June 2014

From the facts of your query it appears that you need some protection against further harassment of legal litigation and some measure to protect your lease right so that if any new landlord comes in the picture he will not get any scope to evict you and to make the agreement or its correction in such manner so that you can enjoy the continuity of your tenancy for a further period.  To achieve such a goal you need help of a Senior Advocate who has some mastery over drafting an agreement and its rectification and knows jugglery of words and its legal interpretations apart from his depth of knowledge in law. But it will cost you.

1 Like

Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register