LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Reservation

Page no : 2

Sudhir Kumar, Advocate (Advocate)     09 July 2016

Originally posted by : Pradeep Garg
Dear all, I strongly oppose the reservation in central govt, state govt & public sector undertakings jobs only on one ground.........these are public services where mostly the common people are dealt with for availing welfare schemes of govt. How the elite class of public servants( a few selected through competitive examination out of lacs of candidates) can serve general public properly with respect of general public?? Since the salaries & perks of these public servants are much better than similar profile in private jobs besides job security, these jobs have become a heavy burden on public exchequer. Why the govt is not prosecuted for wasting public exchequer on these white elephants if employees of same calibre can be hired for much less remuneration without any job gaurantee or security???

"Since the salaries & perks of these public servants are much better than similar profile in private jobs besides job security"

 

why should it not be.  whose rose voice while prior to 4th PC govt servants had very poor wages.

Sudhir Kumar, Advocate (Advocate)     09 July 2016

Originally posted by : Pradeep Garg
Dear all, I strongly oppose the reservation in central govt, state govt & public sector undertakings jobs only on one ground.........these are public services where mostly the common people are dealt with for availing welfare schemes of govt. How the elite class of public servants( a few selected through competitive examination out of lacs of candidates) can serve general public properly with respect of general public?? Since the salaries & perks of these public servants are much better than similar profile in private jobs besides job security, these jobs have become a heavy burden on public exchequer. Why the govt is not prosecuted for wasting public exchequer on these white elephants if employees of same calibre can be hired for much less remuneration without any job gaurantee or security???

what have you done to oppose reservation.  writing blogs on this forum cannot remove reservation.

Sudhir Kumar, Advocate (Advocate)     09 July 2016

Originally posted by : venkatesh Rao
I always oppose reservation in public appointments.

Merited and eligible are victims. 

what have you done to oppose reservation.  writing blogs on this forum cannot remove reservation. 

 

Your profile indicates that you are retired Govt servant.  If you have retired obviously with pension that means throughout you kept serving the govt with reservation policy and never opposed.

Oppsing and Disliking are two different verbs.

Sh. P Suresh (For To By Green Kindness Perpetuity Selfsustainability Always)     09 July 2016

9.7.2016

Sir,

Please list all measures that will end Reservatiion once for all.

Sh. P. Suresh

Sudhir Kumar, Advocate (Advocate)     09 July 2016

please see

 

https://www.lawyersclubindia.com/forum/details.asp?mod_id=138633&offset=1

 

Mr GNL Prasad gave you some advise. read it.  apply hre also.

Sh. P Suresh (For To By Green Kindness Perpetuity Selfsustainability Always)     09 July 2016

The advices by Sh. GLN Prasad in that post are as follows:

POST NO: 1 

THE ROAD TO A BRIDGE SO THAT THE AREA COULD BE USED BY THE CAMPUS & THE ROAD ALSO COULD RUN THROUGHWANT URGENT LEGAL ADVICE, HELP FOR THIS PUBLIC CAUSE, HUMANE CAUSE PLEASE, PLEASE.

 Who has to decide on what is good for Public, and who has powers to act.  We may have many intentions, but it is the competent authority that has to decide and take ation in larger public interest.  One action may appear proper for one, and it may not appear as such to others.
 
The only remedy is filing petitions / complaints after obtaining all necessary documents through RTI, and filing  PIL or writ against the authorities in HC.  Contact a competent advocate, as he has to be with you and guide in entire process.
 
 
----------XXXXXXXXXX----------
 
POST NO: 2

Immediately visit District Legal Services Authority and seek their aid as the issue is in larger public interest.

 
--------------------XXXXXXXXXXX------------
 
WHOLEHEARTED THANKS TO BOTH THE MATURE & TIMELY ADVICES.
 
WELL, THE ADVICE TO GO THROUGH THE FORMER ADVICE ALSO DOES MAKE SENSE. Even at the start, it is pertinent to place it on record that quiet a bit of homework has been done. Competent RTIs have already been filed on Reservation & also on Census, Data Collection, Data Collectors, Processes, Formats, Proofs, Criterias, Justifications etc etc. Despite these detailed RTIs including several possible aspects, they may not be the end of it. But, I am very sure, they throw sufficient details. All said & done, be sure that this matter will definitely reach the topmost court. Thus, it will need thorough brain storming, thorough preparation. Let it be remembered that no bad is meant to anyone. But, DEFINITELY NO ONE WILL BE ALLOWED TO EAT ON SOMEONE ELSE'S PLATTER FOR 30-45 YEARS UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCE, WHOEVER, WHATEVER, WHATEVER IT BE. As it has already been clarrified, NO INDIAN SHOULD DIE FOR BASIC NEEDS. But, NO LUXURY. If someone is brilliant, they be enrolled & incubation support be given for 10-15 years. After that it is all what is called as "Military system" in common man's parlance. Then on, everybody, whoever, whoever, top, bottom, this or that will have to satisfy the contributors & then take home their pay packets. No question of claiming right, strike etc. The policy should take care of the huge, diverse population that we are, definitely not the way it is working today. Well lot has already been said, lot more can be shared at apt times. But, as has been suggested, there need be a beginning.
 
I FEEL THE ISSUE NOW IS LIKE MINDED CONSTITUENTS CONTRIBUTING THEIR MIGHT IN TRANSPARENT MANNER FOR THE CAUSE ON HAND.
 
HOW MANY TAKERS? WHAT ARE BEING COMMITTED?

Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register