LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

ANEESH TRIVEDI (ADVOCATE) (Advocate)     21 December 2014

Same facts in civil and criminal case

In written statements of secton09 restitution of conjugal rights wife gave the same facts and allegation as she alleged in FIR for 498A

decesion of section 09 is in husband favor. like " patni ne patni ko na to sahrrik rup se paratadit kiya na mansik rup se patni ko adesh*t kiya jata hai ko wo pati ke saath jakar avilamb rup se dampatya sambando ko nirvah kar"

question is ; section 09 was filed one months ago than wife filed FIR

tha facts given by wife in section 09 was true copy of complete FIR. by considering and discussing all the fact and after cross wife and her mother [ she is witness in 498A] the decision of section 09 is in husband favor:

[1] this decision also binds on FIR of 498A [as facts are same so decision must be near to it]

[2] section 09 decision given by district judge of same court where in same lower court 498A is under trial so lower court judge can reverse the finding of district judge on same facts discussed five years ago on which no appeal and no objection taken by wife  side/

[3] how much extend the decision of civil case on same facts and from court is helpful in criminal cases on same facts from same court?

[4] what citation ruling judgments should be helpful if anyone having please provide them?



Learning

 2 Replies

Advocate Kappil Cchandna (Expert Bail & Criminal Defence Lawyer at Delhi Supreme Court of India)     21 December 2014

Dear, I will have persuasive value, but not binding ... Kapil Chandna Adv . 9899011450

ANEESH TRIVEDI (ADVOCATE) (Advocate)     22 December 2014

Originally posted by : Kapil Chandna
Dear,

I will have persuasive value, but not binding ...

Kapil Chandna Adv . 9899011450

Agreed but can these citation be used in trial in lower court.

if it is not binding then how lower court judge gave reverse judgement against the finding of district judge on the same fact in the same court .

is this possible?

i Mean for the same cause two different judgments form the same court and that also be against higher authority.............how can be justified..?

above all when the District judge has given the judgment no objection, and no appeal agaist the order for the same fact in same court?


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  


Related Threads


Loading