LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Raj Kumar Makkad (Adv P & H High Court Chandigarh)     19 July 2010

THE PRISONERS NEED A SECOND CHANCE FOR THEY MAY BE PATIENTS

It is a scientifically proven fact that criminals have a structural and biological basis in their brain for asocial and criminal behaviour. A person with frontal lobe malfunction will be oblivious to the pain suffered by his victims. A person with deficiency in the amygdala could behave impulsively, without thinking of the consequences of his criminal activities. These people are likely to be repeat offenders, who simply keep returning to the prison incurring a huge cost to the state treasury and repeatedly wasting the precious time of the police and the judiciary.

The convict is kept in state custody in a prison under the watchful eyes of guards. Neither in view of their

training nor by experience can they provide any rehabilitation to the prisoners, who range from hardcore criminals to petty offenders.

 

The major outcome of this exercise would be exposure to fellow criminals, sharing of criminal ideas, networking among criminals and joint operations of unlawful activities. The minor outcome is some criminals giving up crime due to the hardships experienced and the stigma of being held in a prison.

 

Environmental factors

 

People can also be involved in crime due to environmental factors; frequent interactions with offenders and exposure to criminal activities. Similarly, people can be involved in crime, due to a lack of skills to pursue any job for livelihood.

 

It is commendable of the prison authorities to have initiated educational opportunities; now prisoners can write school and degree course examinations. So also they are exposed to yoga and religious rituals and discourses; all of these can be of enormous influence in changing their mind towards socially acceptable behaviour.

 

Over and above, prisoners require a multidisciplinary team with expertise in bio-psycho-social disciplines to facilitate treatment and rehabilitation. Prisoners, who have disorders of the brain, require the help of a neurologist or neurosurgeon, while behavioural and emotional disturbances can be treated by a psychiatrist. If a person has paranoia, he can suffer from a suspicion that others are planning to attack him or even kill him. A psychiatrist can set right this problem in about month's time with medication. Paedophilia is a s*xual disorder which requires treatment with medication and psychotherapy.

 

A psychotherapist can enable them to modify their dysfunctional thought process, beliefs and emotional reactions which lead them to criminal activities. A clinical social worker would be able to initiate a procedure to correct destructive behavioural patterns, pathological family dynamics and environmental influences of criminal activities. A rehabilitation psychologist would be able to find the aptitude of the person and can guide him to choose appropriate vocational training.

 

The multidisciplinary team needs to have a very clear role definition and also be officially involved in all decisions related to the prisoner. Each discipline bringing its body of knowledge can enhance the state's effort to enable the person to lead a crime-free life, thereby cleansing society.

All prisoners should be considered patients unless proved otherwise!

 



Learning

 5 Replies

Anil Agrawal (Retired)     27 July 2010

Dear all,

Manu Sharma was granted parole. One of the grounds was that his business was suffering. Hang our heads in shame at the chicanery of our politicians and police.

We talk of law.

This is how law is implemented.

Anil Agrawal (Retired)     27 July 2010

Two more grounds:

1. Anniversary of grandmother's death.

2. Mother's illness

He stays at Chandigarh.

He was found in a bar drinking heavily and creating a rumpus. His way of tending his mother and participation in the anniversary celebration.

When he was drinking at the bar, his mother was holding a press conference.

Bhartiya No. 1 (Nationalist)     28 July 2010

"Ladla" of her mother get spoiled like this only. It is his upbringing which has sent him jail. His mother will be happy with this achievment. Simply defending her son blindly, with a belief whatever "ladla" does is right..

Bhartiya No. 1 (Nationalist)     28 July 2010

@ Rajji,

Physiology of brain is only worth reading, medical science has not reached so far. Psychiatrist are not capable to do whta u have desribed. A Psychiatrist of AIIMS commited suicide. Identifying diseases and finding a cure for it is different. Even advanced countries like USA and UK are far away from providing such type of treatment. U may visit any Mental hospital and get the real picture. Even there is no cure for a basic disease like depression, schizophrenia, OCD , mania etc.

Kleptomania.is an irresistible urge to steal items of trivial value. People with this disorder are compelled to steal things, generally, but not limited to, objects of little or no significant value, such as pens, paper clips, paper, fleces and tape. Some kleptomaniacs may not even be aware that they have committed the theft.


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register