Should there be accountability for judiciary? |
|
| Yes | 50 % |
 |
|
| No | 41 % |
|
|
|
| Can't say | 9 % |
|
|
|
| Total Votes Cast : 774 | |
| Submitted By - Guest | Read Comments |
| Posted by A. A. JOSE |
03/11/2008 12:15:42 |
| THERE CANNOT BE TWO OPINIONS ON THE ISSUE. JUDICIARY MUST BE FULLY ACCOUNTABLE. | |
| Posted by Ajay kumar singh |
28/10/2008 19:55:07 |
| Obviously yes. | |
| Posted by A.Rengarajan |
21/09/2008 20:27:18 |
| there should be accountability for judiciary | |
| Posted by Member (Account Deleted) |
21/09/2008 17:14:28 |
| yes.yes.yes.because i was in the judiciary for two and half decades as a judicial officer. | |
| Posted by Member (Account Deleted) |
21/09/2008 16:58:39 |
| yes yes | |
| Posted by amritanshumisra |
20/09/2008 14:56:01 |
| yes, bcoz they are the ones on him the faith of the public rests! | |
| Posted by Member (Account Deleted) |
19/09/2008 14:31:55 |
| yes, there should be transparency in judiciary. | |
| Posted by Raj Kumar Sharma |
18/09/2008 20:07:58 |
| Judiciary shall not be accountable | |
| Posted by D.ANANDHAGIRI |
18/09/2008 16:04:07 |
| yes | |
| Posted by D.ANANDHAGIRI |
18/09/2008 16:04:06 |
| yes | |
| Posted by Veeresh |
17/09/2008 21:41:25 |
| When every one is held one is held accountable for the acts/ommisions why not judiciary | |
| Posted by mohammad aarif khan silawat |
17/09/2008 20:43:48 |
| duty is duty | |
| Posted by nagaraj.k |
17/09/2008 19:35:52 |
| becaush of my carrier in to judicial dept, this is one reason.but judiciary is a one the accountability.thank you. | |
| Posted by chirag |
17/09/2008 15:09:42 |
| i have a two fold view point on this issue: 1. why are judges opposing or avoiding the present issue, if they are so immaculate? 2. tranparency differentiates democracy from dictatorship. | |
| Posted by ch.padmarao |
17/09/2008 13:37:34 |
| judiciary shouldnot be accountable, because it can act independently. indian legal system is much better than any other judicial,judges are accountable to the judiciery only. | |
| Posted by ch.padmarao |
17/09/2008 13:35:00 |
| yes, judiciary shouldnot be accountable, because it can act independently. indian legal system is much better than any other judicial,judges are accountable to the judiciery only. | |
| Posted by ch.padmarao |
17/09/2008 13:10:27 |
| verygood | |
| Posted by Akshadharan P R S |
15/09/2008 21:58:55 |
| Yes. There should be. | |
| Posted by Aniruddha.P.Pawse |
15/09/2008 14:03:06 |
| Even our Hon'ble President, Prime Minister and Chief Justice of India have agreed that some percentage of corruption have started in the Judiciary. In such circumstaces accountability for judiciary is necessary. | |
| Posted by dalipkumar_nic |
15/09/2008 12:08:48 |
| ya, why should judiciary leave from the accountability? and whats the wrong with that?. It will enhance the faith of judiciary in general public. | |
| Posted by Alok Pathak |
14/09/2008 10:53:27 |
| Yes It is necessary to check whether the judiciary work under the ambit of law & constitution? Other wise there may be a possibility to act arbitrary. Accountable Judiciary, my strong believe, would be work more effectively and according to Law . | |
| Posted by ankur |
13/09/2008 22:44:16 |
| offcourse | |
| Posted by vikas mishra |
13/09/2008 09:52:22 |
| judiciary should be accountable for thejudjements hey give, becaue than they would be easily prone to corruption | |
| Posted by mr.suresh v.patankar |
12/09/2008 23:39:49 |
| we have trust in legale system the laws are human people | |
| Posted by VASANTH D JAGANATH |
12/09/2008 20:22:48 |
| accountability should be there even in judiciary also, otherwise its going to be serious issue. it might get corrupt also | |
| Posted by Member (Account Deleted) |
12/09/2008 16:42:13 |
| I joined the bar in 1971 and joined judiciary in 1981 and took V.R.S. in may 2006. I strongly feel that judiciary should be accountable. | |
| Posted by G. ARAVINTHAN |
11/09/2008 20:29:32 |
| I agree with all these. But now arise the question that how they should be? There must be a forum/commission to look after this system | |
| Posted by Gaurav Jain |
11/09/2008 20:03:03 |
| it would reduce the level of acquiital of accused from the court's net. | |
| Posted by Mansur INDIAN |
11/09/2008 14:43:32 |
| Yes, there has to be accountability for judiciary, but, not by anyone certainly. It has to be a exper and experienced panel of lawyer and justice in it’s certain parameter. | |
| Posted by xyzpqrstnmnmmm |
11/09/2008 08:15:11 |
| Yes. There should be accountability for judiciary. | |
| Posted by Kiran Kumar |
10/09/2008 07:47:19 |
| let the judiciary act in transparent manner.....fewer times High Court judges would act like Kings with no accountability towards anyone. its a larger issue and must be discussed in forum. | |
| Posted by pabba sandeep |
09/09/2008 19:45:30 |
| judiciary must not be accountable so it can act independently | |
| Posted by Deepak |
09/09/2008 18:27:45 |
| yes | |
| Posted by sachin naagar |
09/09/2008 13:28:15 |
| i do not understand why this topic needs a debate at all,anybody who has a power or powers which could directly or indirectly effect another persons life and assets should me made accountable,why not judiciary specially when corruption in judiciary can not be denied. | |
| Posted by Satyaprakash Sharma |
09/09/2008 10:52:49 |
| Sure. Then only, Honesty and Integrity could be ensured. | |
| Posted by ganesh |
09/09/2008 10:40:33 |
| Yes, because surely the accountability will make a filter of some untowards... At the same time the perfect guard is required.. | |
| Posted by ankit gupta |
08/09/2008 22:32:36 |
| this is to maintain independence of the judiciary. | |
| Posted by JAYLAL JAISINGH BISUKARMA |
08/09/2008 21:22:25 |
| Judiciary is an independent body and its independency means, full and true soverginity of our nation. It will be only be in dictatorship that judicary will be an accountable. To be 'fair and just' judicary must be independant and not accoutable....(from Adv. J.J.Bisukarma, Advocate, Bombay, High Court.) | |
| Posted by shikha raje sisodia |
08/09/2008 16:45:53 |
| In a democratic country like India every institution which serve as a piller to its very foundation should be limited by checks and balances otherwise a kind of anarchy will arise. Judiary however in the upper level of its heirarchy is doing very well but nobody except the suffering litigents in the lower judiciary knows the darker side of that bright visual. | |
| Posted by Adv.Shine Thomas |
08/09/2008 11:22:09 |
| Yes,only an impartial and independent Judiciary can protect the rights of the individual. | |
| Posted by Vinodkumar Kotabagi |
07/09/2008 23:19:27 |
| Judiciary without accountability is like riding a horse without control over it. | |
| Posted by KamalNayanSaxena |
07/09/2008 21:06:23 |
| Not only for Judiciary but should be for each and every Department | |
| Posted by Pankaj Rai |
07/09/2008 18:58:01 |
| THERE SHOULD BE NO ACCOUNTABILITY JUDICIARY IS SEPARATE. | |
| Posted by RADHA PYARI SRIPADA |
07/09/2008 17:25:40 |
| it is desirable but how do we bring about is more important. | |
| Posted by Vishal Gupta |
07/09/2008 05:54:24 |
| why not | |
| Posted by Rakesh Shekhawat |
06/09/2008 22:24:25 |
| Why not because Power without liability always creates some sort of dictatorship. | |
| Posted by Krishnan Venkatachalam |
06/09/2008 21:27:22 |
| Yes. Judiciary is one of the field that upholds freedom and when this field enjoys the freedom bestowed by our constitution and it can decide the fate of the society, it should not be misused. Hence accountability is required. | |
| Posted by A.G.Syam kumar |
06/09/2008 20:44:16 |
| because some how poor interpretation and faithless justification | |
| Posted by adv fauzia azim |
06/09/2008 20:35:48 |
| why not, judiciary is comprised of human beings only,and it is only normal to make some mistakes,therefore the judiciary should be accountable for all decisions.judiciary is the backbone of any democratic country.so,all the more reason. | |
| Posted by V.Raghavan |
06/09/2008 19:16:42 |
| Just by passing orders the duties of the courts are not ending. The judiciary is also to monitor the execution proceedings so as to confirm the object and the very purpose of passing the order is obtained. | |
| Posted by arun agrawal |
06/09/2008 18:48:54 |
| Law is for everyone and it (the judicial system) should be made more transparent and accountable. | |
| Posted by SUSANTA KR MUKHOPADHYAY |
05/09/2008 22:51:56 |
| YES | |
| Posted by SUSANTA KR MUKHOPADHYAY |
05/09/2008 22:51:53 |
| YES | |
| Posted by Dayanandan P T |
05/09/2008 17:55:28 |
| yes | |
| Posted by TS Bhatia |
05/09/2008 11:59:10 |
| Yes everyone is accountable for his actions ,so should be judiciary. | |
| Posted by venkatakrishnamachary |
04/09/2008 21:02:24 |
| the judiciary has great responsibility and the system should be fair and impartial.The judges and magistrates are accuntable to the judiciary only and the accountability should not effect the judicial descretion in delivering judgements | |
| Posted by venkatakrishnamachary |
04/09/2008 20:41:49 |
| judiciary has great responsibilty of protect the rights of the public, apart from render justice to the needy people | |
| Posted by Rajan Salvi |
04/09/2008 18:08:47 |
| Definitely. The discretion vested in the Judges ought to be exercised as per law laid down by the Supreme Court as well as the Legislated laws. It is not an unbridled power. In fact the various stages of appeals/Revision and subordination of Courts is because , the Legislature knew that no one is infallible.The mistakes made by Lower court are open to question in the Higher Judiciary. My contention is that Judiciary should be accountable but not to the Legislature and Executive , but to Judiciary itself. Settled precedents should govern as greater minds have applied their intelligence to the subject in question | |
| Posted by Harish Shaha |
04/09/2008 16:01:31 |
| They are also not above the law hence accountability is must for fairplay. | |
| Posted by CSSR Venugopal |
04/09/2008 10:30:30 |
| Yes judiciary should be acccountable to the respective selfconscious of judges. And certainly they are accountable to constitution. | |
| Posted by K.C.Suresh |
04/09/2008 04:50:32 |
| Accountability means responsible or expected to give an explanation. Responsible to whom? To the Law and legal system. Explantion to whom the higherups. This two are parrellel but must be compromised at some point of time. That depends on the system, situation he handles. How ever Indian legal system is much better than any other for the judicial accountability to the Law, Justice, State and PEOPLE. | |
| Posted by K.C.Suresh |
04/09/2008 04:47:59 |
| Accountability means responsible or expected to give an explanation. Responsible to whom? To the Law and legal system. Explantion to whom the higherups. This two are parrellel but must be compromised at some point of time. That depends on the system, situation he handeles. How ever infdian legal system is musch better than any other for the judicial accountability to the Law, Justice, State and PEOPLE. | |
| Posted by Tribhuwan Pandey |
03/09/2008 20:41:42 |
| Yes judicial system should be impartial and fair. | |
| Posted by G. ARAVINTHAN |
03/09/2008 12:59:41 |
| Yes the Judges are answerable for justice they provide in each case. Though the judgment is their opinion, they are accountable to their Higher Athority. If required, they have to produce or submit their report, | |
© 2024 LAWyersclubindia.com. Let us grow stronger by mutual exchange of knowledge.
