Should Executive play a role in appointment of judges to higher judiciary? |
|
| Yes | 27 % |
 |
|
| No | 70 % |
|
|
|
| Cant Say | 1 % |
|
|
|
| _ | 1 % |
|
|
|
| Total Votes Cast : 88 | |
| Submitted By - Prakash Yedhula | Read Comments |
| Posted by Member (Account Deleted) |
11/11/2010 07:31:23 |
| because the executive (ruling parties are executives ) may or many times appoint their well wishers or their followers. So theere may not a impartial judgement against or in matters of government matters | |
| Posted by Arati Gawde |
10/11/2010 20:33:02 |
| . | |
| Posted by VIJAY BABU MADIPALLI |
10/11/2010 19:03:55 |
| My vote is for "NO", | |
| Posted by Vikas Kumar |
10/11/2010 18:59:19 |
| Just as delivering justice is prerogative of Judiciary similarly appointment is the prerogative of executive and a detailed check on executive is kept by legislature.If appointment in judiciary is done by judiciary itself then nepotism and favouratism will be a mundane affair in appointment.So a more balanced approach is required in appointment e.g. a supreme court judge should be appointed on recommendation of committee which includes persons of all three wings viz executive , legislature and judiciary or may be like American system some parliamentary recommendation like thing may suffice | |
| Posted by anand |
09/11/2010 22:02:02 |
| if it is allowed then it will be indirect supremacy o executive over judiciry and which is unconstitutional | |
| Posted by Mugundhan |
09/11/2010 15:57:37 |
| Executive interference in judiciary is a threat to democracy. | |
| Posted by Advocate Bhartesh goyal |
09/11/2010 10:21:40 |
| no | |
| Posted by Advocate Bhartesh goyal |
09/11/2010 10:21:40 |
| no | |
| Posted by Arvind Singh Chauhan |
07/11/2010 16:54:09 |
| I am with Kiran Kumar Sir. | |
| Posted by G. ARAVINTHAN |
06/11/2010 21:53:08 |
| Executive - Legislative - Judiciary All the above three are interlinked and there will be a part for the other two in the appointment of Judicial Officers even at the stage of Higher Judiciary | |
| Posted by ROHITASHVA PURI |
06/11/2010 12:29:11 |
| judiciary is independent itself its dosent need any type of suggessition | |
| Posted by Sanjay Gowda |
06/11/2010 11:36:18 |
| No, executive should not interfere with the Judiciary! | |
| Posted by Kirti Kar Tripathi |
05/11/2010 18:41:09 |
| let one organ to work. otherwise, there will be no hope. | |
| Posted by Suchitra. S |
04/11/2010 06:39:23 |
| I completely agree with Mr. Kiran Kumar. | |
| Posted by Kiran Kumar |
04/11/2010 05:52:30 |
| infact role of executive is already there in the judicial appointments. its not only the plitico-administrative nexus is prevalent in this county but judiciary is also a part of this nexus. one could see a lot of incompetent people rising to the judicial post with their political backings. when the state govt. and central govt. are being headed by the same party and further the President is of the same party then How one could expect an impartial appointment of a judge? | |
| Posted by kiran rathee |
03/11/2010 14:16:18 |
| there should not be any interference as three organs of the govt are independent.. | |
| Posted by sripada VRS |
03/11/2010 07:58:31 |
| we choose judges by choice and select capable to execute in his/her powers accordingly. we not give chance to no one. do it now. | |
| Posted by niranjan |
02/11/2010 22:16:20 |
| If the final verdict of appointment is tobe given by the executives, they may also play role in decesive factor too. | |
| Posted by Bhartiya No. 1 |
02/11/2010 21:48:39 |
| This will make the situation a very chaotic and from bad to worse. | |
| Posted by Parthasarathi Loganathan |
02/11/2010 19:24:54 |
| Definitely not as it would pave way of intervention of political parties to influence the highest chair of the court. | |
| Posted by Jayaprakash Narayan |
02/11/2010 19:23:55 |
| Yes.. Involvement of Executive is necessary as empowering a single organ would lead to over power and distribution of power would dilute and give more transparency. | |
| Posted by Member (Account Deleted) |
02/11/2010 15:44:13 |
| Executive through President of India and Prime Minister of India already involved in process making why a wing whose actions are directly under challenge in courts are given given an opportunity to influence independent character of Judiciary | |
© 2024 LAWyersclubindia.com. Let us grow stronger by mutual exchange of knowledge.
