LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More


(Guest)

GIVING BRIBE UNDER PRESSURE NOT A CRIME

GIVING BRIBE UNDER PRESSURE IS NOT A CRIME AS PER A LATEST STUDY BY DLEHI HC. ITS ONLY UNDER PRESSURE THAT A MAN GIVES BRIBE . ITS ALSO RECOMMENDED TO PARLIAMENT TO MAKE BRIBE GIVING NON PUNISHABLE . GIVING BRIBE IS A COMMENDABLE EFFORT BY A MAN TO GET HIS ILLEGAL WORKS DONE UNDER PRESSURE.



Learning

 55 Replies

DR.SANAT KUMAR DASH (Eye Specialist)     23 October 2010

Please    submit     the    full     Judgment     of   the     Delhi   High   Court,   so    that    all   the   members     will    know    the      decision.   It   will     be    a    guidance     &     future    reference.

Roshni B.. (For justice and dignity)     23 October 2010

@ sony

LOL!

atleast u admit that lareke wale take these "bribes".....good.

the entire system asks for bribes.it's polluted.wot can bribe givers do?

if they refuse to give this bribe,they will hardly get a good match for their daughter.even if they get one,the family she's wedded into may start torturing for this "bribe" afterwards.and this results in litigation of many yrs. and perhaps a divorce.so there's no guarantee that a so called simple family who did not ask for this "bribe" will treat the bahu properly post marriage.

 

and in this way, parents are actually forced into giving this bribe.THEY ARE NOT AT FAULT

 

if parents act idealistic b4 marriage & want to complain legally against the bribe askers,they will again get engaged into long litigation.and u know how "great" our indian legal system is....and how "fast" an innocent person gets justice.so no one wants to get involved into these litigations.

and they end up paying this "bribe" to avoid these ugly legal battles later on.

 

now after reading all this,wot do u suggest to bribe givers who gave under pressure pre-marriage?

lets talk of the solution instead of focussing on the problem and beating about the bush..

1 Like

RAKESH JADLY (FIELD WORKER)     23 October 2010

please have full contents of this judgement of high court


(Guest)

WHY THEY AGREE THEIR DAUGHTERS TO SUCH GUYS. THERE IS NO DEARTH OF GOOD BOYS.

1 Like

Bhartiya No. 1 (Nationalist)     23 October 2010

Yes,

It is true that no one like to pay bribe, but they pay under compulsion.

Also the bribe takers lay trap, and ensures that without paying no one can escape or there is no way out. Bribe taker work more hard in this regard.

In that case paying is not that much offence as taking.


(Guest)

so wat is solution to eliminate this problem?

why not stop giving bribe from 2011.

why not NCW MAKES A WIDESPREAD CAMPAIGN TO STOP IT AT INSTANT , REGISTER ALL MARRIAGES IN COURT.  ALL unregistered marriages be treated as illegal.

Arup (UNEMPLOYED)     23 October 2010

" Yes,

It is true that no one like to pay bribe, but they pay under compulsion."

it is not always true.

some manipulators like contractors, suppliers very oftenly use bribes as an weapon against their rivals.

3 Like

Bhartiya No. 1 (Nationalist)     23 October 2010

Sony Madam Your concern is genuine. We mustat least try to stop bribing.

There are so many govt agencies like the Central Vigilance Commission (CVC), the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI), Central Information Commission (CIC) and the Controller Auditor General (CAG). These are all anti-corruption agencies but they are not seems enough. Unless we do something we will not the good result.

Here corrupts and bribe/dowry takers are outsmarting us and are working overtime twice as hard to continue their illegal practices and failing all the measures of ours.

Arup (UNEMPLOYED)     23 October 2010

some manipulators like contractors, suppliers very oftenly use bribes as an weapon against their rivals.

SAME THINGH HAPPENED WITH MATRIMONIAL MANIPULATORS ALSO.

SUPPOSE A GOOD LOOKING GIRL AND AN UGLY GIRL OFFERED A BOY TO MARRY. NATURALLY,THE BOY WILL CHOICE THE GOOD LOOKING GIRL.

NOW TO SNATCH THIS MATRIMONIAL OFFER, UGLY GIRL OFFERED

UGLY GIRL + CAR + FLAT ETC. A SIMPLE PACKAGE DEAL.

ON THE CONTRAY GOOD LOOKING GIRL IS POOR AND NO MONETORY OFFER.

THE BOY ACCEPTED THE PACKAGE DEAL.

NOW WHY NOT THE UGLY GIRL WILL BE PUNISHED FOR PAYING DOWRY?

3 Like

(Guest)

ALL marriages be registered in court.

all those not registered after notification of law be declared as  illegal.

all marriages shud have no dowry, no gift affidavit signed.

all marriages shud have prenupital contract drafted by both sides advocates stating clearly terms of marraige, alimony in case of divorce, means assets and qualification / any specicic material fact  of both spouses . so that later on there is no allegation of cheating.

there was a govt directive to make registration of marriages as mandatory in this regard but nothing has happened yet.

3 Like

Arup (UNEMPLOYED)     23 October 2010

ms  sony,

your above guidelines are ideal but not practical.

cause of giving dowry is  mainly for the manipulation between the contested parties.

as i said above. simple economic theory also activated there.

2 Like

Arup (UNEMPLOYED)     23 October 2010

as i said above, simple economic theory also activated there.

THEREFORE SIMPLE IDEOLOGY WILL NOT WORK PROPERLY..

DOWERY CASES WHICH ARE NOT REPORTED ARE MORE IN NUMBERS THAN THE REPORTED CASES.

I FEEL HURT WHEN FEW YOUNG MEN TAKES THE DOWRY AS A STATUS SIMBLE OF THEIR IN LAWS FAMILY.

HERE IS A TIPS  - IF YOU FOUND A DISSIMILAR COPLE, YOU MAY TRACE THERE, MAY BE  A DOWRY CASE.

 

ALL DOWRY CASES ARE NOT REPORTED ONLY A FEW REPORTED.

INSTEAD OF LEGAL ACTIONS, WE SHOULD LET IT COME IN PUBLIC, BY WHICH SOCIAL ACCOUNTABILITY COMES OUT.

2 Like

Arup (UNEMPLOYED)     23 October 2010

BEFORE MARRIAGE DOWRY SHOULD BE CLEARED IN WRITTING BY BOTH THE SIDES AND IT SHOULD BE FREE FROM ALL LEGAL ENCROACHMENT. LET THE PEOPLE ALLOW ACCORDING TO THEIR WILL.

 

AFTER MARRIAGE IT MUST NOT BE ALLOWED.

2 Like

Isaac Gabriel (Advocate)     23 October 2010

"Give and Take " is not a crime, if at all the process is completed satisfactorily between the 'Giver and Taker'.


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register