LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Vinod (self)     21 December 2010

Is Civ. Revision Petition allowed at Bombay HC after...

Is Civil Revision Petition maintainable (at the admission stage of petition vide 'legal bar on revision, limitation' as well as on 'merits/contents') at Bombay HC against the interim order  (HMA, sec 24, in favour of Petitioner-wife) passed by Family Court , especially in the following likely scenarios as a aftermath to the order?

 

 

If Respondent-husband prefers to file for review at the same FC (mainly bcos he wants to adduce new startling evidence, in his favour, which wasn't available earlier and there are material irregularities in the order)

 

 

If he goes directly to HC for revision, he would be deprived from filing that new evidence (please correct me if this is a wrong understanding) This is the biggest worry for me!!!!

 

 

If Family Court rejects the review application also, then husband is left with two adjudications to bear i.e.

  1. an Order to pay maint  (Order no. XYZ)
  2. A dismissal of his 'Review Application no. ABC' to which prevented from further appeal.

And he would have lost the time also.

 

 

Order 47 rule 7 of CPC says:Order of rejection not appealable

 

 

Does that infer as........... although Husband can't appeal in HC to plead that 'Erroneously, my previous order isn't being taken for re-hearing at Fam Court?' But  Husband is still not barred  by law to go to HC with a revision plea to Order no. XYZ, and to pray at HC by Civil Revision as follows.........

  1. 'kindly revise the order no. XYZ, and also kindly do consider the 'evidence adduced' during Review no. ABC although it is dismissed by family court'
  2. 'And although husband had merits, lower court didn't even look at the new evidence...and this has caused material irregularity and grave injustice is done to husband'

 

 

What the husband is achieving here is that...............Although He is going to HC for a revision after dismissal of review...he is going for revision with that new evidence onboard!!!!! And HC always looks at the matter afresh even though family court may be reluctant to appreciate the 'relevancy' of that new evidence

 

 

  

Please give your opinions. This is really urgent. Thanks.



Learning

 1 Replies

neel (self)     19 January 2011

Hi vinod,

 

Can you please contact me   neel.jamun@gmail.com    /send me PM

 

 

What was the outcome of review petition? I hope you got what you asked for.....

Were you asked to pay arrears first? How much did you pay from that?

I have many things to ask...please contact me Sir

 

 

Do you know about further steps if nothing happens in 'review'? Are you allowed to appeal/revision at HC.

 

 

If you have appropriate formats of application, please send it to me:-  neel.jamun@gmail.com

 

 

I desperately need advise from you Sir.

 

 

Thanks in advance


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register