LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Anuj Kathuria   08 December 2024

Labour issue

Sir,

Our firm only employee had starting absenting from service from June, 2019 onwards .We sent him letters requiring him to join duty immediately to which he did not reply. He then sent us lawyers notice demanding exorbitant amount with the charge of removing from job without notice to which we did not reply . We came to know that he had started working as contractual labour in another city since 2019 .We were under impression that the matter was closed . After 4 years ,he sent us demand notice in August ,2023 with charges of pending earned wages (01-05-2023 to 31-07-2023) and removal from job without notice on 31-07-2023 . We filed our reply to demand notice stating that he was absent from service from 2019. He then filed complaint with labour office and matter was referred to labour court as settlement could not be made .We filed our reply after receiving summons from court and next date of hearing is 10-03-2025.

We have filed RTI with Postal department to confirm his service as contractual labour with postal department along with date of joining ,name of contractor and last salary drawn but no reply has been received till date .  We have also sent registered post letter to superintendent of posts along with copy of RTI for necessary immediate action. Please advice the process ,application format to obtain call records ,mobile location for Vodafone UP West prepaid mobile connection for the period 01-05-2023 to 31-07-2023. Can the same be used as evidence to confirm employee absence from service ?

Please advice.



Learning

 6 Replies

T. Kalaiselvan, Advocate (Advocate)     08 December 2024

 phone call records from a service provider can be used as evidence in court in India if they meet certain conditions.

PROVIDED, All participants in the conversation must consent to the recording.

The conversation must be relevant to the matter being investigated.

The recording must be accurate, and the possibility of it being tampered with must be eliminated..

The recording must meet the conditions set out in Section 65B of the Indian Evidence Act..

The Supreme Court has ruled that electronic evidence must be presented before the trial begins, and the court can order the production of certificates at any point before the trial ends.

 

1 Like

Dr. J C Vashista (Advocate )     09 December 2024

How does postal department to entertain your application under the provisions of RTI Act came in between you and your sole ex-employee, who is stated to have been long absent and joined some other company in other city / state before sending you another notice for outstanding amount ?

Confusing and vague story, redraft

or 

seek professional service of a local prudent lawyer for appreciaiton of facts and professional advise / necessary proceeding.

1 Like

Anuj Kathuria   13 December 2024

T. Kalaiselvan, Advocate sir, thanks a lot for your advice. 

T. Kalaiselvan, Advocate (Advocate)     13 December 2024

You are welcome Mr. Anuj Kathuria for your appreciations and understanding.

1 Like

Anuj Kathuria   15 December 2024

Dr J.C Vashishta

Sir ,thanks a lot for your advice.

We came to know after enquiry that he is working as contractual labour with postal department. Hence .filed RTI. Reply received yesterday from postal department that they cannot provide third party information.

Dr. J C Vashista (Advocate )     15 December 2024

Let another application u/s 6 of the RTI Act, 2005 be filed by someone of his kith and kin, then it will not be a third party.


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register