DO YOU THINK REFERRING CASES RELATING TO MAJOR OFFENCES SUCH AS 376,498A IPC TO THE MEDIATION FOR SETTLEMENT IS GOOD IN THE EYE OF LAW? (IT OFTEN HAPPENS WHEN A PERSON SEEKING ANTICIPATORY BAIL FOR THE ABOVE OFFENCES)
R. PON KARTHIKEYAN (ADVOCATE) 28 July 2010
DO YOU THINK REFERRING CASES RELATING TO MAJOR OFFENCES SUCH AS 376,498A IPC TO THE MEDIATION FOR SETTLEMENT IS GOOD IN THE EYE OF LAW? (IT OFTEN HAPPENS WHEN A PERSON SEEKING ANTICIPATORY BAIL FOR THE ABOVE OFFENCES)
S. Bharath (Advocate and Arbitrator Formerly Civil Judge) 28 July 2010
Reference to Mediation per se cannot be viewed as a bad idea, if either the victim or the accused does not find it ok, it is open to him/her to seek the matter be remitted back to the regular legal process. Given the present legal system which does not offer great control/participation of the victim in regular trial, mediation is an option worth exploring.
R. PON KARTHIKEYAN (ADVOCATE) 03 August 2010
In my point of view, when an anticipatory bail petition for major offences(498A,376,420)filed before a highcourt and on hearing, some of them are being referred to the mediation centre for an amicable settlement,if that reference too accepted by the defacto complainant and prosecution, then the Court which refers the case should presume to some extent that the allegations levelled by the prosecution is fabricated since the prosecution along with the defacto complainant itself intending to settle the issues among the parties amicably, so under this circumstances when a mediation fails and the matter is remitted back to the high court for disposal, the court should consider in the above prospective and should grant anticipatory bail to the accused instead of dismissal or compelling for a withdrawal...
Sameer Sharma (Advocate) 03 August 2010
"Mediation is a process aiming at creating and repairing social ties and managing conflict between people, whereby an independent and impartial third party organizes exchanges between the conflicting parties to improve relationships and solve conflicts." In my personal opinion mediation can be used in non-cognizable and compoundable offences where gravity of crime is less. Cases u/s 376 and 498A, are of serious crimes, they cannot be judged by mediator or third party, it can only be decided in Criminal Courts.