LCI Learning
Master the Basics of Legal Drafting in All Courts. Register Now!

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

saran kumar (na)     06 April 2014

New argument in appeal

  1. A has got into sales deed agreement with B.
  2. B did not have enough money, could not pay A for getting sales deed done.
  3. B bought credit, drawn DDs, filled a suit that A is not comming for registration, than with drew DDs.
  4. A did not rise asking about the source of income of B in the court.
  5. Court passes decree in favour of B.
  6. A appealed
  7. CAN A ASK B TO ESTABLISH SOURCE OF INCOME IN APPEAL COURT .

Thanks in advance.



 6 Replies

shanmugam lakshmanan (senior)     06 April 2014

No. crucial issue of readyness & willingness proved in suit. Borrowal loan proves B's ability to mobilis the fund. That will do for specific performance of agreement. 

cyberlawyer (barrister)     06 April 2014

^^ agreed...

Shantilal Pandya ( Advocate)     07 April 2014

I agree  with other experts and submit that a plea which  is not taken earlier  is constructively  barred by resjudicata.you can consider Explanation  4 to section 11 of the code of civil procedure.

saran kumar (na)     09 April 2014

Hello sir,

i the above case both the parties came to settle the matter out of the court (now case is in the appeal court) i.e, got in to a new agreement of sales deed in which

1) B has to cancel the appeal before 1 month.

2)A has to pay B in three months and get he sale deed registered by B.

If B withdraws appeal from the appeal court can A be able to approach lower court and ask the court to execute its decree which was stayed by appeal court ?

if yes how can B secure his bona fides?

saran kumar (na)     09 April 2014

Hello sir,

i the above case both the parties came to settle the matter out of the court (now case is in the appeal court) i.e, got in to a new agreement of sales deed in which

1) B has to cancel the appeal before 1 month.

2)A has to pay B in three months and get he sale deed registered by B.

If B withdraws appeal from the appeal court can A be able to approach lower court and ask the court to execute its decree which was stayed by appeal court ?

if yes how can B secure his bona fides?

shanmugam lakshmanan (senior)     11 April 2014

Withdrawal of Appeal not necessary. Both of you can enter into a compromise decree in appellate curt itself and terms of compromise will bind both parties. Good wishes.


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register