LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Sanjay   10 July 2017

Wrongful employment termination

Till last week I was working with a private Company in their IT division as Architect(Not Managerial grade), there is a team of people who report to me and one of the female subordinate had alleged false s*xual allegation against me 2 weeks back and after submitting my report against allegations I was terminated by the Company citing(exact words being) - During the investigation, the Company has discovered that you disregarded the safety of your subordinate. You did not avoid the appearance of impropriety, and as such showed lack of judgment as a line manager.

The allegation was put on a day when we were in US in a hotel's social evening hours where there was another male subordinate who was there with us throughout the evening and for a brief period during the evening he had moved out to make a call(which is where the allegation is put) and had rejoined us till we all had amicably dispersed. The female subordinate had been drinking throughout the evening.

The Company when terminating has offered me 3 months of pay and has given me a clean certificate of employment.

I am very confused with all this and trying to find if the Company is within its rights to terminate me or this can be challenged, definitely not understanding the Company’s use of word ‘safety’ in termination letter. Also, if challenged then what should I expect towards compensation and do such cases drag for a long time, is it worth to fight?

Please advice.



Learning

 15 Replies

Arjun Kohli   10 July 2017

There could be several grounds on which such issue could be challenged. First of all, the bye-laws of the Sexual Harrassment Committee can be explored and looked up if there is some inconsistency with regard to the procedure, constitution, process, decision etc. 

Moreover, you could appeal against the same decision in the appropriate tribunal or forum, with respect to the service rules applicable to you.

If you succeed in the case, definitely you can claim a decent compensation and damages for the injury to your reputation as well as your career. However, it can't be guaranteed that you would succeed only. Hence, you will have to probably engage a capable counsel and analyse your case critically and figure out if it would really be worth the effort or not, or you could gather as much as legal opinion about it and decide for yourself.

Kumar Doab (FIN)     10 July 2017

Do you mean to post that despite your reply and evidence the company has contradicted?

If yes, has company shared any evidence on the basis of which it has concluded termination?

The termination order is subsequent to so called inquiry/investigation whatever it is, and from your post it seems that it i stigmatic.

It is not clear how do you presume that company has given you clean certificate.

During BGV refernce check the company may open personnel file  and report th exact reason.

 

 

 

Kumar Doab (FIN)     10 July 2017

Approach with case file a very able local senior counsel of unshakable repute and integrity specializing in service matters for a considered opinion.

 

Kumar Doab (FIN)     10 July 2017

While posting such queries employee should post basic information!

What is this establishment; Commercial, Industrial?

What is its nature of business say; IT, ITeS?

How many persons are employed in it?

What is your designation and nature of duties?

How many persons report to you?

Do you have any power to sanction leave/increment/appoint/terminate/appraise etc etc ?

You are in which state? Since how many months you are working?

Do standing orders (model/certified) apply to establishment and your designation?

What is notice period as per appointment letter/offer letter and what was notice period tendered by

you?

Was ever any stinker, memo, show cause notice on any misconduct issued to you?

Are you a member of employee’s/trade unions?

Has the establishment issued/supplied, salary slips of all months, PF number and a/c slips of all

years, ESIC card,?

 

 

Sanjay   10 July 2017

I had one and only meeting in the beginning with the Sexual Harassment Committee where I was helped in recording my statement which after making changes I had submitted as 'Acknowledged' statement per HR telling me to do so. There had been no evidence against me which HR had acknowledged and none have been provided to me. After a week the Company has unilaterally terminated me with the reason exact verbiage on my first post as is on the termination letter along with giving me clean 'Experience letter' for the duration of employment and along with it 3 months of salary. They wanted me to sign the letter accepting 3 months pay and giving consent that there would not be any claim filed by me in future.

Kumar Doab (FIN)     10 July 2017

Originally posted by : Sanjay
I had one and only meeting in the beginning with the Sexual Harassment Committee where I was helped in recording my statement which after making changes I had submitted as 'Acknowledged' statement per HR telling me to do so. There had been no evidence against me which HR had acknowledged and none have been provided to me. After a week the Company has unilaterally terminated me with the reason exact verbiage on my first post as is on the termination letter along with giving me clean 'Experience letter' for the duration of employment and along with it 3 months of salary. They wanted me to sign the letter accepting 3 months pay and giving consent that there would not be any claim filed by me in future.

 

Were you given a typed statement? Apparently you have NO evidence for it also.

Has HR person acknowledged in writing that there is NO evidence against you? Apparently NO.

The said experience letter with no insertion of termination may/may not be of any use as during BGV exact reason/investigation may be revealed.

Do you have an evidence say; CCTV footage with audio that you were not involved and wre innocent?

It is entirely your call to pursue the matter in a manner suitable to you.

 

Sanjay   10 July 2017

I had submitted a typed statement. So, this is where my question- Is my Company wrong in terminating me based on allegations(when it's not proven) and citing misconduct. Do I have a case where I can sue the Company and make them pay some heavy fine.

Kumar Doab (FIN)     10 July 2017

If you are not at fault, are not given proper and natural hearing, the inquiry is sham, the termination is bad then you can agitate....................

Award by court of law is pleasure and discretion of court. 

Court decides on facts and merits.

Arjun Kohli   10 July 2017

Ofcourse, they have to give adequate reasons for terminating you and mention the grounds and supporting evidence in the same concern. If you are not satisifed with the same, it is in your due right to appeal against the said decision. A reasonable case can be made out on your behalf citing the practical realities of the events in which the harassment was particularly complained of, and your particular role on it and the proportion of the punishment imposed with regard to the responsibility, whatever it be.

Principles of Natural Justice are a principal guiding factor for such committees to decide the cases. It definitely follows up that proper justification should be handed out to the aggrieved. 

Kumar Doab (FIN)     10 July 2017

Does your contract of employment has some clause on Arbitration also!

Sanjay   10 July 2017

There is no clause of Arbitration.

Kumar Doab (FIN)     10 July 2017

In that case role of arbitrator per arbitration clause can not be imposed.

The facts of the matter can come out during reference check/BGV.

Spend some quality time alongwith all docs on record with local counsel as already suggested and understand all options and merits. 

Sanjay   11 July 2017

Please recommend lawyer in pune who comes with reputation and can aggressively handle my case.

Kumar Doab (FIN)     13 July 2017

Preferably check at Labor Court/CGIT, Civil Courts and chose.

The employee's/trade unions leaders, elders of your family,well wishers,colleagues, DBA officials etc can guide you.

Once you inquire you need to firm up your fee,T&C etc on your own.


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register