LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

KARAN SINGH (SERVICE)     27 July 2012

How to avoid maintenance

dear experts ;

1, wife desert house along with 5.6 months old daughter from delhi and leaves with her father to her home. later without knowledge of husn]band withdraws TC from school

2Husbant tries to contact in laws but was informed wife along with daughter left for an unknown undisclosed place. All efforts to contact  speak meet them forf husband fail

3,husband files RCR from place of marriage and sec 26 ; meanwhile lady files 13 1 A

4, since daughter was isolated forcefully for past 8 months and all effort to contact fail  hence husband files GWA . on same date wife files Maint for daughte

5 Question is :-

        (a)  if husband be made to pay for maintenance since the daughter has been forcefully removed from      custody

   (b)  does it not be in favour of husband that he wants custody of daughter as he feels wife is in job and now it seems that by asking for maintenance for daughter she is financially not in a condition to support her and father  is willing to take her back

regards 



Learning

 1 Replies

Tajobsindia (Senior Partner )     27 July 2012

Originally posted by : kamlesh bisht
  husband files RCR from place of marriage and sec 26 
since daughter was isolated forcefully for past 8 months and all effort to contact fail  hence husband files GWA on same date wife files Maint for daughte

(a)  if husband be made to pay for maintenance since the daughter has been forcefully removed from  custody
(b)  does it not be in favour of husband that he wants custody of daughter as he feels wife is in job and now it seems that by asking for maintenance for daughter she is financially not in a condition to support her and father  is willing to take her back
 
 

 First simultaneous proceedings under S. 26 HMA and under provisions of GWA act is barred by Law. You have to disclose this to either court and get one withdrawn and then only is able to continue with one suit for custody. Do withdraw one before her side's advocate points out at crucial moment and you get depressed later on !

Now for your two questions;

1. Maint. to daughter till decision on her permanent custody is independent rights of daughter via her guardian on whose behalf maint. case was filed.
You have already filed for custody rights by invoking two petitions simultaneously so you are within your rights till decision of the Court favours you with custody, but till then you have to meet the maint. for a child if and when it gets awarded. However child maint. are always co-extensive means both parents have to bear that.


2. Financial capacity to claim custody by guardian / natural guardian are one of the factors within preview of S. 17 GWA under which consideration during trial is made as to who among the two is fit parent to grant custody. By mere asking maint. that can always be brought as adverse argument point in GWA and or in S. 26 HMA proceedings but is a controversial sole criteria to give custody to you as per few State HC’s views.


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register