kavksatyanarayana (subregistrar/supdt.(retired)) 13 May 2021
Father executed a Will favouring his sons. But during his lifetime, he sold that property as per your query. He bought another property and for this new property, there is no Will. Hence all the legal heirs including his wife and daughters of the father have equal share over the property.
Sankaranarayanan (Advocate) 14 May 2021
yes all the legalheirs are equal entitlement share over the property. i do endorse expert Mr satyanaraya sir's answer
SIVARAMAPRASAD KAPPAGANTU (Retired Manager) 14 May 2021
Any Will Registered or otherwise comes into effect only after the death of the person who wrote the Will. As per your query, your Father passed away after selling the property described in the Will he earlier wrote. The property which was bequeathed in the Registered Will is no longer available. Therefore, for the existing property, it has to be taken that your Father Passed away intestate. Clarification to your pointwise queries are as follows:
Sir, in reply to your response, Father had only one property for which he made the will. While selling that property heade his sons party sellers in the sale deed and then purchased new property. As soon as he purchased new property he did not have chance to get updated his legal documents as he passed away. Therefore, Making a will in his son's name, then making them party to the sale deed also. Aren't these enough to draw intentions of the Father and doesn't the Law say that Last intention of the Owner be respected ?
Will request your thoughts on this .
SIVARAMAPRASAD KAPPAGANTU (Retired Manager) 14 May 2021
Your query clearly mentions as follows:
"...Making the sons part of sale deed and bought the new property out of proceeds by the father only in his name...."
Making the Sons party/ies to the willed property sold by your father, before his passing away, was not required and it was infructuous. Intentions which are not in writing are not valid before the Courts. If you wish the intentions of your father to be brought into the picture, you may have a family meeting with the Elders have a discussion and come to an amicable solution and write a settlement deed that needs to be registered.
M V Gupta (Advocate) 14 May 2021
Wills are generally drafted to cover not only properties in existence but also future acquisitions by the testator. So it is necessary to check the provisions made in the will. If it is stated that your father bequeaths all his future acquisitions also to his sons to the exclusion of daughters then your sisters will not have any claim to them. and you brothers can deal with the properties in such manner you may deem fit. The above view is on the basis that the properties in question are his self acquired and not ancestral properties.
Sir exactly the point you have converted. The Father X had the sole property and no other property while making the will so he was naturally to mention of that property only. Now when that property is sold making his sons part sellers, and replacing a new property out of sale proceeds, where does the intentions change or dispute ?
Earlier also X hand single property, presently also X is having the sole property, just that the property details have changed. How does that go point to a change of mind or intentions not to act according to the old will ?
Also the earlier sold property Father 'X' got from his mother and X's father through succession and was not X's self acquired. X and his living mother jointly wrote a will in name of the sons. Do this fact play some role please guide..
Please provide your inputs
P. Venu (Advocate) 14 May 2021
The question that arises is - did the Will cover future acquisitions also. Any suggestions depends upon the words in the Will as to the property bequeathed.
Anand Bali Adv. (Advocate Solicitor & Consultant) 14 May 2021
The laws relating to the Will are very strict. It is clarified by many of the Hon'ble court judgments that the rights of any benefit to be derived out of the Will shall be only confined with in the boundaries of the wordings of the Will ant not beyond it. So if there is no mention of any future property in the Will, No right against any they future property can be derived and in that case, in such a situation all the legal heirs of the deceased person shall have their respective equal share out of that future property in the case of the Hindu succession Act. However, in the case of non-Hindus, their respective Personal laws of succession will be attracted to give succession to that future property. I endorse many of my other colleagues as mentioned above.
Sir, please sugget what should be done now to somehow bring the old Registered will to some use in any manner so as to get the property into sons name and where can it be presented and what procedure can be followed ? Rest the authority you suggest may decide what can be done. Please guide through means of procedures which can be initiated by the sons now.
SIVARAMAPRASAD KAPPAGANTU (Retired Manager) 15 May 2021
Dear Sir,
Enough clarification was already given by the Experts including the possible mention of future assets (meaning the property purchased a brief period before death ) of the deceased about which you haven't clarified.
Had your Father while purchasing the property with sale proceeds of the Willed property, besides making Sons as party to the sale, should have purchased the property in the joint name of the Sons instead of in his own name. As you have mentioned about intentions of the deceased person, it would have been very clear and would have " almost avoided " any future litigation from any quarter.
Somehow to link present property in the name of the deceased about which there is no mention in the Will is fraught with the risk of the property being open for litigation in future and prospective buyer may not be convinced about the marketable title of the said property.
P. Venu (Advocate) 15 May 2021
Originally posted by : Vijay shankar | ||
Sir, please sugget what should be done now to somehow bring the old Registered will to some use in any manner so as to get the property into sons name and where can it be presented and what procedure can be followed ? Rest the authority you suggest may decide what can be done. Please guide through means of procedures which can be initiated by the sons now. |
Is this query posted as one among the beneficiaries of the Will or in the capacity of the advocate for the beneficiary?
T. Kalaiselvan, Advocate (Advocate) 15 May 2021
The Will of your deceased father was for the property which ws sold during his lifetime, hence the Will becomes infructuous once the schedule of property mentioned in the Will is no more available.
Your father did not make any Will involving the present property hence this property shall devolve equally on all his legal heirs which includes his daughters as well.