Castration is NOT a logical punishment atall.1) Because castration will stop s*x.The punishment should be such that, that will stop rape not s*x. Sex is very good for health and a biological need. Consent s*x is good for health.But if a person is castrated then he will not able to have s*x any more. It is not logical.
Punishment should be such that, that will stop rape not s*x.
But castration will stop s*x. That is not logical.
2)A person can not be castrated against his will.
If rape is a violence then castrating a person against his will also a violence.
3) Castrating a person against his will is a violation of human rights and was a punishment of middle age.
4) Castrated person may become more violent and may become a misogamist and misogynist. A castrated person may start hating girls. Castrated person may start harming girls because of extreme anger.
5) Intercourse is not the only way of violence. Those who exhibits violence against girls may use other ways for violence.
6)The corrective method must be used before giving any punishment. The method should be such that , that the rapist can understand his faults and can correct himself.
7)Method of Castration can be misused in Police station. Innocent persons may be castrated. Already the dowry law has been misused in India.
8)The person who will be castrated may become mentally and psycologically ill and may become a misanthropist. He may harm other people because of anger towards mankind.
9) A person doesn't have any right to castrate other person. There can not be any eye for eye punishment.
Chemical and surgical both are brutal form of punishment. Both are wrong punishment.