Gourang M Haldipur 14 September 2016
N.K.Assumi (Advocate) 15 September 2016
I think you are rfering to Janaki Vashdeo Bhokjwani case, regrding Order 3 rule 1 & 2: Yes there is another decision A.C.Naryanan Vs State of Maharasthranr and Anr 2007: but which is in different context, without any serious conflicts.
AV Bagur Advocate (Advocate ) 15 September 2016
This is a good judgement as on date.