LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Vasant (abc)     12 April 2013

Daughters

Hi,

I've gone through a lot of forums and primarily it looks that the daughter will not have any share in property acquired by Father, in case the father died in 2000 ( i.e. before the Hindu Succession Act (Amendment) 2005 came into effect). But i want to check from the experts if daughters would be entitled to the share in agricultral land acquired by father in the following case:

1. Father died in 2000 leaving no will.

2. The property was purchased by father in 1970.

3. Father wanted to sell the property in 1996, the sale didn't go through as intended. The sale transaction of the property was under a legal disputed being heard in the Delhi high court (from 1996 onwards) as there was a dispute between buyer and seller(us). After Father's death in 1999, daughters were acknowledged respondent to this case by the Hon'ble high Court.

3. More recently the Hon'ble High Court has invalidated the intedned sale transaction and has ordered respondents (us) to pay specific damages which are being paid by all (Including daughters).  Hence, as of today, the property in still under the name of the father who passed way in 1995. Having said that,  the property is still undivided as of today.

I request learned experts to comment if the daughters would be entitled to thier share in Agricultural land if the property is to be divided as of today. I understand that the father should have been alive in as of  2005 for this to be the case but given that daughters have already paid the damages to counter party as specified by the Hon'ble court, would daughters stand any chance?

Thanks

Basant Singh



Learning

 4 Replies

Adv Archana Deshmukh (Practicing Advocate)     12 April 2013

As you say that the property was purchased by the father in 1970 i.e it is the self acquired property of the father. So the daughter being class I heir of the father has the right to have equal share in the property along with their brothers and other heirs( wife and mother of the deceased) if any.

ADVOCATE Prem Joshi (Advocate/ Legal Consultant)     12 April 2013

Ld Archana is right, follow the advice

Vasant (abc)     12 April 2013

Thank you. In one of the judgement, in 2006, Hon'ble Supreme Court had held that in case of fatehr's death before 2005, notinal partition is deemed to have coocured at the time of father's death and hence no share is to be given to duaghters. Was that the case only for ancestral propetry and not self acquired property.

a.chop (student)     12 April 2013

can you plz advice in our case we are a muslim family (sunni) in which my father has died and has left no will and we are 2 sisters and a brother. we have the property that has to be divided. so if you could plz advice on the division of the property according to muslim law in india and also there is a house in which my brother has 50% of share and rest was in the name of my father so how will the distribution take place.and also does daughters have a share in the agriculture land in muslim law, i will appreciate your early reply.


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register