LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

gaurav singh (clerk)     28 November 2013

Help to save maintenance

Dear Expert Sirs,

I am from Indore and she is from Bhopal.  I am submitting my story in brief regarding my query as under:-

1. I Filed application U/s 13 on 10, Aug 2010  for Divorce at Indore Famiily Court. and  I got Ex Partee Decree Divorce on 18/07/2011 from Court. It is not Ex partee purely as she got summons from my court and appeared one time at my court and get time to file reply of my petition bt neither she appeared not filed reply of my application. so I got Ex Partee Decree Divorce on 18/07/2011 from Indore Family Court.

2. In June 2012 i got summons from Bhopal Family Court U/s 125 for maintenance. she filed application U/s 125 in Nov 2010 at Bhopal family court.  bt i got summons in June 2012. 

3. She filed application for Set Aside of my Ex partee Divorce Decree in Aug 2012 and it was rejected on 9 Nov 2013 as i submitted several evidences before Indore court about her absense and false application for set aside of my divorce decree . 

4. I have filed reply of her petition for maintenance case at her court Bhopal family court including order of set aside and the false facts which she submitted before Indore court which shown her FALSE SUBMISSION OF EVIDENCE BEFORE COURT. I hv proved it with so many evidences. 

5. Now stage of case U/s 125 is at HEARING OF INTERIM MAINTENANCE APPLICATION. 

My query is that:-

1. How can I contest against her  maintenance case which is extremely false case. 

2. I am govt employee and my net salary is 25000 P M , if maintenance order passed against me whether Interim or final wht amount may be AWARDED against me. 

3. I got evidence that she had applied in govt teacher exam intimating about 3 years experience of teaching in school bt  i could not find which school it is mentioned only 3 years in the form. can it be helpful fr me . 

4. my Ex Partee Decree issued frst to me and after that  i got summon for her case U/s 125, further her application for set aside  for  decree has been rejected also as it was totally false  grounded application. CAN IT BE HELPFUL FOR ME TO CONTEST THE CASE U/S 125 .

5 I am already re married well and settled family bt  she has not re married till now as per my knowledge till date. 

SIRS PLEASE SUGGEST ME

GORAV SINGH



Learning

 3 Replies


(Guest)

You will have to pay her alimony till the day she remarries.


Alimony will be calculated 1/3rd on take home income.  So you should tell the court your total income minus expenditure such as.. Loans, insurance, medical bills, electricity bills, internet bills, telephone bills, etc and also provide bills to court to the tune of last six months for it to verify.  Finally 1/3rd of take home salary will be decided as alimony.


If you have proof that your wife has applied for govt job etc, such details be made aware to the court along with her educational qualifications etc and also can ask for appointment of Court Commissioner if you want details about her non-movable assets which you are not aware of.


And after taking into consideration what your wifes educational qualification is, what her assets are [non-movable] and your take home income is, then court fix alimony. 


And also state to the court that you are already re-married.


(Guest)

Hello Gaurav.

The objects of Section 125 of CrPC as stated by the Supreme Court in various judgments like D.Velusamy vs D.Patchaiammal, and Vimala (K) vs. Veeraswamy (K) [(1991) 2 SCC 375], are that Section 125 of the Code of 1973 is meant to achieve a social purpose and the object is to prevent vagrancy and destitution. Explaining the meaning of the word `wife' the Court held that the object is to prevent vagrancy and destitution. It provides a speedy remedy for the supply of food, clothing and shelter to the deserted wife. Initially, a misconception existed that a working woman is not entitled to claim maintenance as she is earning and is thus able to maintain herself.

Now, based on the judgments in cases like Bhagwan v. Kamla Devi and Chaturbhuj v. Sita Bai, it is not evident that she can claim maintenance from her husband in spite of her efforts to earn a monthly income if that is not enough for her maintenance. It also clarifies that the expression ‘unable to maintain herself’ does not require a wife to be absolute destitute before she can apply for maintenance. Also, merely for the reason the woman is qualified, does not dis-entitle her from claiming maintenance under Section 125, CrPC, as it was held by the Kerela High Court in the Muraleedharan vs Vijayalakshmi case (II (2006) DMC 613, 2006 (3) KLT 635). In this case the judges stated that ''the plight and the situation of even the educated half of the Indian polity show clearly that the qualification by itself cannot be held to be synonymous with ability to maintain themselves. Many a qualified housewife after marriage relegates herself to the kitchen and the home front looking after children.” However, in cases where the wife claims maintenance under Section 125, she must positively aver in her petition that she is unable to maintain herself in addition to the facts that her husband has sufficient means to maintain her and that he has neglected to maintain her. Usually, the Courts on granting interim maintenance, takes into consideration the condition of both parties.

Hence, you may raise the plea of your income as well as the qualification and working status of your wife. Though this will not entirely shield you from paying her maintenance, it may nevertheless be helpful in determining the amount to be paid as interim maintenance.

 

–Regards,

Advocate Pooja

www.lawkonect.com

Adv. Chandrasekhar (Advocate)     02 December 2013

As per law, an indigent divorced wife is entitled to maintenance u/s. 125 cr.p.c. till she remarries.  If she is unemployed, you will have to pay maintenance.  There are a few cases where divorce is granted to husband on the ground of wife's desertion without reasonable cause, such husband has absolved from the liability of paying maintenance.  But they are rare.  As you have already a full fledged family, the court will take into consideration of your and your family's expenses out of your income and quantify a reasonable amount for her to survive.  If she is in employment at present, you prove that fact to escape such liability.


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register