LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Naresh (In search of job)     06 December 2010

How to approach high court for speed up trial?

Dear members,

 

I had filed for divorce in june 2007, till now it has not even come for cross examination. Each time the judge is giving 1 month long dates. For the past 5 hearings (5 months), it is just pending to be cross me, but the opposite party rejected to cross me on the ground that I haven't paid maintenance. Last time, judge asked me to pay the maintenance or else he would dismiss my divorce petition, then I had prayed that I'm jobless and so would not be able to pay all the amount at once as I am without a job and currently studying and give me time, will pay in installments. For which judge rejected my prayer and ordered me to pay the amount in FULL, otherwise he will dismiss my petition.

 

So, this time, I had collected money from my relatives/friends and paid her FULL money and asked judge to cross examine me and complete my case before the end of December 2010, as there is a chance of agitations going to start in hyderabad after december.

 

But the judge didn't accept to my plea and gave again long date after december (i.e first week of january). When I requested him to keep the early date, he rejected saying that there are lot many people apart from me and with the current load of cases, my case will take 3 more years.

(1) In your view, do you think it is a fit case to go for appeal in HC to speed up the matter? If so, what reason's I need to quote in my appeal to HC for speed up trial? Please point to me to any related judgments related to speed up of trial?

 

(2) I have only divorce (sec 13(1)(a)), and maintenance u/s 18 HMA currently, in which wife in her counter also asks for divorce but on her grounds of impotency. In this situation, what is your realistic view of my divorce case completion? Since, in my view, I think only my cross examination and her cross examination is enough to decide the matter? Is this right?

 

Please advice.



Learning

 5 Replies

ashish lal (Advocacy)     06 December 2010

No, it is not a fit case for approaching HC.

If both parties want divorce then get the dispute resolved through mediation.

N.K.Assumi (Advocate)     06 December 2010

If the Court is  satisfied that both the spouse are desirous of snapping the marriage no extra legalistic approach is required for the court and it matters little whether petition is on the grounds of divorce by mutual consent or not. the Court should always look at the substance and not the mere form of the petition.

Naresh (In search of job)     06 December 2010

Dear ashish sir and assumi sir,

 

Mediation is done in lok-adalat but the wife side is demanding huge alimony (more than 15 L), which I can't afford to pay, I'm jobless for the past one year. Also, her mediation terms are uncommon, she wants impotency to be mentioned in the decree. So, the mediation failed and referred back to the family court from lok-adalat.

 

In this situation, what I can do. Actually, I approached court thinking that the matter would be decided in 18 months as is the norm to complete the matter in family court as my first lawyer told me. Later, it is being dragged by courts as well as my wife party as she is neither interested to live with me neither wants to cooperate to complete the matter quickly, and the court's delayed justice is perfectly suits to her requirement.

 

(1) In any case, could you please explain me the procedure from now onwards till the final order comes. The current stage is they have to cross examine me and I don't have any witnesses. To decide the matter, if they cross examine me and we cross examine them is sufficient for the court to decide the matter? That is two more proper hearings is just required to decide the matter!!! Is not it?

 

Please explain what more stages can be there to get the final order?

KNK A Learner (Learning to share)     08 December 2010

Hi Naresh,

Speedy trail is fundalmental right of every citizen according to Constitution of india. Infact supreme court guided the lower courts to speed up the divorce case and finish off within 6 months, but that's not happening. According to Constitution of india. Every citizen has right to leave in peace and has right to have good s*xual life.

Go to HC saying that the allegations of Impotency is effecting your mind and going to impact your future s*xual life if the case takes long time to settle. So request the HC to finalize the case within 6months of time without futher damage you mind and s*xual life and also mention the financial status of yours to consider for speedy trail.

All the best.

Naresh (In search of job)     08 December 2010

 

Thank you KNK sir,

 

For your kind reply and also the valid reasons you have mentioned for me to approach the HC for the speedy trial.

 

Can someone (learned advocates and members), please post the favourable decisions in the speed up trial petitions please.


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  


Related Threads


Loading