LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

ESNishanth (self employee)     11 December 2016

HUF Property

all property belongs to my grand father G he had three son A B C and two daughters D E. three sons A B C one daughter D died G ALSO died . E(daughter of G) had three sons s1 s2 s3. in 2008 S2 asked registered POA from E S1 S3 for some purpose. by trusting S2 words E S1 S3 signed the document, finally S2 had missapropriated and made fraudlent by change of gift deed instead of POA DEED in SRO OFFICE and got registered signature from E S1 S3 as gift deed . by 2015 we found it and cancelled the gift deed by three members E S1 S3 SIGNATURE IN SRO OFFICE and informed to S2 the next day. on 24 Nov 2016 S2 had send a lawyer notice from G M ANANTHA KUMAR CHENNAI ADVOCATE by stating ilateral cancellation to three members E S1 S3. actually E is an cancer patient now she cured but some times not felling well. What shall we do please suggest and incase if challenged what will be the judgement. A B C D have legal heirs. all are HUF property.



Learning

 11 Replies

Kumar Doab (FIN)     11 December 2016

Show all docs on record to a very able counsel specializing in such/property/civil matters.

It is believed that G and all are Hindu.

Confirm!

If POA is valid then agent can act within rights defined in POA. Both Principle and agent must have appeared before Registering authority.

 

Gift deed can be cancelled with explicit consent of donor and donee. Both donor and donee must have appeared before Registering authority.

In your case Registering authority has just registered cancellation of gift.

Court alone can revoke the gift deed.

 

 

 

 

ESNishanth (self employee)     11 December 2016

@kumar Doab : thanks but actually S2 have smartly cheated E S1 S3 and got registered sign . so what can be done. by document writer we have cancelled the gift deed. since tax corporation recipt are all in name of G

Kumar Doab (FIN)     11 December 2016

Both Principle/donor and agent/donee must have appeared before Registering authority.

On what grounds now you conclude the averments!

 

Kumar Doab (FIN)     11 December 2016

Averments are to be established in court to the satisfaction of court to revoke the gift .

 

 

ESNishanth (self employee)     11 December 2016

thats what asking . how to reply for the notice

Kumar Doab (FIN)     11 December 2016

Approach a very able counsel with full case record and provide your inputs.

Your own counsel based on record and inputs shall draft the reply to legal notice.

Avoid remaining silent.

Adv. K.S.A.Narasimha Rao (legalquestadvisor@gmail.com )     13 December 2016

Dear E S Nishanth,

You have stated that only the proeprty is HUF property, but it is not clearly said whether the property is still joint in nature or nuclear. If there is a partition among the brothers and sisters of E, then the subject property becomes a self acquired property of E and rightly or wrongly you have made mistake in executing a POA/GIFT and the unilateral cancellation will not hold good and losing of the case is at higher end.

If there is no specific partition, all the other family members may have chance to file a suit against all of you i.e. E, S1, S2 & S3 for cancellation of Gift Deed/POA, which is executed by E, S1 & S3 in favour of S2 illegally without any valid right over the same.

ESNishanth (self employee)     13 December 2016

@ K S A Narasimha Rao : No partion were happen still today all property are in name of G still are joint and HUF . Whether if E S1 S3 can win if S2 file a suit on E S1 S3 for cancellation of gift deed. For S1 and S3 dont have title in the property still E is mom of S1 and S3 , E is alive but in gift deed S2 got sign from S1 and S3. in this case if S2 file a suit whether E S1 S3 will won..?

Adv. K.S.A.Narasimha Rao (legalquestadvisor@gmail.com )     13 December 2016

Dear Nishanth,

1. No partion were happen still today all property are in name of G still are joint and HUF.

    Once G" died, how can it be still under HUF?

2. Whether if E S1 S3 can win if S2 file a suit on E S1 S3 for cancellation of gift deed.

     No scope to win by E, S1 & S3, unless you have a strong evidence to show that they were compelled to sign before registrar concerned.

3. For S1 and S3 dont have title in the property still E is mom of S1 and S3 , E is alive but in gift deed S2 got sign from S1 and S3. in this case if S2 file a suit whether E S1 S3 will won..?

I could not understand the above sentence.
 

S2 have good chances to get declaration of "Deed of Cancellation of Gift" as null and void through Court if he files case before the Court. However, in the eye of law the document executed by E, S1 & S3 is void and non operative as per the earlier judgements passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court and various High Courts.

 

ESNishanth (self employee)     13 December 2016

K S A Narasimha rao : its undivided property for E . G is father of E .

ESNishanth (self employee)     13 December 2016

K S A Narasimha rao : its undivided property for E . G is father of E .

Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register