LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

shri (tech lead)     28 January 2015

Nagative feedback inexperience certificate

Hi All, This is RAVI my wife worked 2 years for one of small scale It company in pune.she served notice period got released properly but in experience latter They have given negative feed back like intermediate performer,many absenteeism s were observed etc due to these negative feedback she is not getting job for last 5 months. Please advise us what to do. Thanks, Ravi


Learning

 1 Replies

Kumar Doab (FIN)     28 January 2015

The easiest solution is thru Employer and it can erase the comments and issue a new one.

Advise her to apply rapport, goodwill, persuasion, persistence skills…. …….

If she is unable to handle on her own then she may approach her employee’s /Trade Unions like CITU-INTUC-AITUC-BMS etc…………………or an able labor Law Consultant/Service Matters Lawyer….

 

If she is not a member of any unions then she has grossly erred. Employees face such situations because they feel that they shall lower their status by becoming member of employee’s unions……………while unions can handle such matters effectively and can negotiate service conditions….

Now there are female IT/ITeS employees unions, IT/ITeS employees unions, and one was floated by Shiv Sena too…………

 

In Maharashtra :

-Trade Unions have traditionally been strong and may agree to represent you……

 

-MRTU,PULP is to defend the rights and Industrial Tribunals can be approached…..for unfair labor practices….

-Managers are also provided opportunity and employer is given opportunity to resolve under PAMS…personal advisory and managerial servicate…….an informal plateform to resolve before reference to appropriate forum…….

 

 

1. Does she have declinature by any of the employer in writing or on record in any form in the last 5 months?

 

2. Did she object to the comments in writing under proper acknowledgment?

 

3. Has the employer ever issued any stinkers to her on the comments stated in experience letter?

 

4. Is the feedback that is stated TRUE?

 

The experience certificate or service certificate is duly explained in Industrial Employment Standing Orders Act /Model Standing Orders; Sec16..........Service card is prescribed and employer has to use the prescribed form/format for it……………………

As per service card available at Delhi Govt website there is no column for stinkers and  there is column for commendations……

 

 

1[FORM V]

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[See Standing Order 1, Schedule I-B]

 

 

 

 

 

Service Card

 

       

 

https://www.delhi.gov.in/wps/wcm/connect/doit_labour/Labour/Home/Acts+Implemented/Details+of+the+Acts+Implemented/The+Industrial+Employment++Act,+1946/The+Industrial+Employment+%28Standing+Orders%29+Central+Rules,+1946

You may check the details as in Maharashtra:

https://mahakamgar.gov.in/MahLabour/acts-rules.htm

 and also relate with Model Standing orders;

https://pblabour.gov.in/pdf/acts_rules/industrial_employment_standing_orders_rules.pdf

 

IT companies in Maharashtra are covered by Bombay Shops and commercial Establishments Act:

 

 

https://mahakamgar.gov.in/MahLabour/images/pdf/the-bombay-shops-establishments-act-1948.pdf

 

 

 that was enacted to govern the service conditions of employees working in such establishments and standing orders are applicable…………as per Bombay Shops and commercial Establishments Act ;Sec38-B, if the establishment   has 50 or more employees standing orders shall be applicable and if standing orders are not certified Model Standing Orders shall apply….

 

 

You may download the various forms that employer has to maintain on the attendance, leave, service card, service certificate etc of employees thru Inspector under  Bombay Shops and commercial Establishments Act and relate the facts……………….

 

Availing leave is not misconduct.

 

Many leaves is also not misconduct.

 

There is nothing called as Intermediate Performer………………(do you have performance data and performance parameters? )

 

Service Certificate does not entail for performance……………

 

 

 

An able lawyer may opine that she can sue the employer for act of zealous mindset, vindication, discriminatory retaliation, defamation,……………………………..


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register