Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Shiv Kumar Sharma (Lerner)     16 June 2012

Violation of sec 173 cr.p.c.

 

Dear Sir;

In this case, the procecution evidence has copleated on last hearing, and the case is now fixed for defence evidence.

Brief facts are as under:

  • The I.O. recived a complaint aginst accused, but he did not reproduced it in F.I.R.
  • I.O. made a enquiry and lodge the case according to its own findings after one year u/s 420,467,468,471,384 IPC.
  • He shown himself as a Complainent in FIR
  • And after investigating the case, another I.O. filed a Final Report u/s 173 Cr.P.C. Showing that there is a lack of evidence and some documents have been send to FSL, further action will be taken after the report from FSL
  • After a period of one year the Court accepted that Final Report.
  • But after accepting the FR by the court the first  I.O. (Who is complainant also) get back in action, He collected the handwriting of one persions, Send it to FSL with the handwriting of accused which he has taken already during investigation.
  • That, this FSL report was against the accused.
  • The Police fieled a new Challan u/s 173 Cr P C u/s 468 & 384 IPC and court framed charges. Matter is pending trial since last 12 years.

On the last date the I.O. of the case has disclosed all the things shown above during cross examination.

My question is at this stage, should I go for defence evidence or I should make a request to stop proceedings as Second Report u/s 173 Cr P C is the result of Reinvestigation after filing a Final Report under said section of Cr.P.C. Which is illegal and bared by Sec 173(8) itself.

If so under which section of Cr p c should I proceed.

Thanks and Regards

Shiv Kumar Sharma



Learning

 3 Replies

LAXMINARAYAN - Sr Advocate. ( solve problems in criminal cases. lawproblems@gmail.com)     16 June 2012

Read and follow ARUSHI MURDER CASE.

Shiv Kumar Sharma (Lerner)     22 June 2012

Res Problem Solver

In Arushi Murder Case, The closure report was presented by police, and Hon;able Court issued notice to the Complainant, Complainant protested the Clouser and Court issued summons to complainant and denied to accept closure and regected the contest by complainant.

But in this case the Court has accepted the Final Report and no permition of further investigation was there by the Court to Police.

In such situation  Wheather he Police may file a Fresh Charge Sheet ? 

LAXMINARAYAN - Sr Advocate. ( solve problems in criminal cases. lawproblems@gmail.com)     23 June 2012

since the ARUSHI murder case has got so mych publcity and hence so many twistes in the case.

In the normal course the case could have been closed.

Now the process is issued to certainly chargesheet.


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  


Related Threads


Loading