Ankur Singhal (Chartered Accountant) 15 February 2017
Jai Karan Nagwan (consultant) 15 February 2017
A female member can not become Karta. Amendment of 2005 was restricted to inclusion of daughter as copacener and nothig else. however Law do not prohibit specifically.
Kumar Doab (FIN) 15 February 2017
Wife is not co-parcener.
So Widow can be a Manager (denoting a role distinct from that of a karta) of a joint family.
Kumar Doab (FIN) 15 February 2017
Probably the matter in original query (1st post in this thread) got mixed up.
Kumar Doab (FIN) 15 February 2017
As per the Hindu Succession ( amendment )Act 2005, that Female Member of joint Hindu
family, having acquired the status of a coparcener from her paternal ancestors as the
status of HUF property even after her marriage and thus she can therefore, form
HUF from the ancestral property with her children being coparceners of this HUF.
Coparcener is a person who enjoys interest in the family property by birth. The coparcener
enjoys right to enforce partition.
Thus the position is clear in case of daughters.