Definition of expert
dev kapoor
(Querist) 10 August 2011
This query is : Resolved
Once I was dealing a case of 'forgery'.Mr.Bhalla,a Handwriting expert belonging to Punjab was to be examined.As soon as he appeared the witness box & before it the routine examination-in-chief started Mr. Bhalla said, of course,after oath, " I am an EXPERT because.." he stated his qualification (i),(ii) (iii)...,I have been in Govt service for the last 20 years,I have appeared in different courts of the country in various cases as Handwriting Expert in more than 200 cases since......My opinion has been admitted by various courts of the country & decision made on them.Among other cases my opinion was upheld & appreciated in Pratap Singh Kairo's case even by Supreme Court reported in AIR.... & he referred many other citations where his expert o[pinion was upheld and...... So I call myself as " Handwriting Expert".Then he made deposition followed by cross-examination.... !
Before We claim Expert,we better take a cue from Bhalla's example.
Many answers are given by our dear Experts but only superficial.KNOWLEDGE KNOWS NO BOUNDS.Let us tell others,no matter even if they are adversaries,if we really mean that 'we are experts'.A little search would make you Distinct.. Keep it up !
Raj Kumar Makkad
(Expert) 10 August 2011
I pay great thanks to Sh. Dev Kapoor ji for teaching us a simple lesson taking example of Bhalla.
I shall try now onwards to mend my ways and come to the true expectations as narrated by him. Again thanks and request to supervise all of us minutely and chase even personally by making personal message. I shall appreciate such constructive approach.
mahendrakumar
(Expert) 11 August 2011
while appreciating Mr.Dev,I feel,his observations would be helpful provided,you point out any lapse on specific cases by experts rather than a general observation.
prabhakar singh
(Expert) 11 August 2011
At least i do not call my self to be an expert as i am a lawyer practicing in civil laws in UP at a district level, i joined Lci, of late ,i saw a Query ,i wanted to answer but site suggested that only experts can answer,and i was guided to apply,i applied ,where after i was listed as an expert.That is all the Story of my being called EXPERT here. Law and jurisprudence behind it has no limits,and at least ,i can not call or name my self as an EXPERT OF LAW,as Mr. Bhalla or several experts in several districts appear in witness box and take oath to claim themselves as an handwriting experts.
M V Gupta
(Expert) 11 August 2011
I do agree that many answers given on this platform are found to be very cursory and some times not touching on the issue raised by the querist. Many a time the answers appear to have been given even without looking into the provisions of relevant laws and even without grasping the point at issue.
M/s. Y-not legal services
(Expert) 11 August 2011
nice mr. kapoor.. here all we are learners.. never i treat my self as experts.. for your kind information, right now am practicing in high court and now calling the justices as LORDSHIP.. but am trying to be an expert in law. if i am an expert in law mean i will call the justice as MR.justice or MISS/MRS.justices only.. with in life, i will..
R.Ramachandran
(Expert) 11 August 2011
To improve the quality in thie Site, I have been requesting the Administrator to do the following:
(i) To appoint a legally trained person to moderate both the queries and answers.
(ii) Neither the query, nor the answer should get flashed on the site unless it has been moderated.
(iii) If the Moderator feels that the query is not clear he should not allow it.
(iv) Similarly, if the answer is not of minimum quality, it should not be allowed.
If this minimum exercise is done, then slowly and steadily the qualify of the contents in this Site will definitely improve.
Others may also like to indicate their view points.
prabhakar singh
(Expert) 11 August 2011
i agree with expressions of Mr. M V Gupta as well as of suggestions of Mr. R.Ramchandran.
M/s. Y-not legal services
(Expert) 11 August 2011
Yes ramachandran sir.. As per your your idea while our mobile conversation as senior members you can contact with mr.prakash. And regulate our forum.
M/s. Y-not legal services
(Expert) 11 August 2011
My humble submission to our senior members, sorry for my rude while answer to anonymus persons. Same time i won't tease or hurt any layman. But if any advocate post any doubts as anonymus mean i getting angry on him. I can't tolerate that. Thats all.
M/s. Y-not legal services
(Expert) 11 August 2011
I request you members, we shouldn't be answers to any advocates who is posting any querys as anonymus only for clear their doubts. If we not answer mean day by day they will changed.. Please do it for little tom.
dev kapoor
(Querist) 11 August 2011
Well friends, Good Evening.Though late but this Forum is becoming a 'habit' now.I get time time almost 'late'...I sleep Late,I rise Late BF etc all late...Nevertheless "kudos".I start feeling I am in the class of 'intelligentsia'.
We resolve to introspect & be fair to 'all'.Well said Mr.M.V Gupta,Mr.tom.advocate,Mr.Prabhakar Singh.I place on record my special thanks to Mr.R.Ramchandran for being upright & sincere.Keep up friends & dear Sirs.I assure I shall not lag behind.But one thing.. 'you all are experts in law'So advoce ppl sincerely.Professional solicitiong apart.
Good Night
