LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Avnish Kaur (Consultant)     07 November 2010

Judge @ high speed upsets lawyers

Monday, 30 August 2010 08:31

Hyderabad, August 29: Justice at jet speed. That is what seems to be the motto of a young civil judge in Andhra Pradesh who has created a national record by disposing of 111 cases on a single day.

For JVV Satyanarayana Murthy, a 40-year-old junior judge in a small coastal town of Mangalagiri, justice brooks no delay. Virtually racing against time, he is on a mission to reduce pendency in his court. On Thursday last, Murthy set a record by delivering judgments in 111 cases, bringing much relief to the litigants. The previous national record was the clearing of 80 cases by a court in Mumbai.

A majority of them were petty cases. In 78 of these cases, the accused had confessed to the offences, resulting in the imposition of fines totalling Rs 99,500. Most of the cases related to theft, street brawls, domestic quarrels and road accidents.

While his zeal to ensure speedy justice brought cheers to the common public, a section of lawyers, however, feels aggrieved. Reason? They stand to lose on monetary front if the cases are disposed of quickly.

“We are happy that our judge has created a national record in delivering speedy justice. We need more and more judges like him to reduce pendency in courts. Though a small section of lawyers feel that they will be deprived of their earnings if the cases are instantly disposed of, everyone else is happy,” the President of Mangalagiri Bar Association, A Sanjeeva Reddy, told The Tribune over phone.

Ever since joining Mangalagiri court in Guntur district in May this year, Murthy has virtually declared a war on pendency. Thanks to his initiatives, the number of pending cases had come down from 1,900 to 1,300 now, Reddy said.

When a group of “aggrieved” lawyers approached the judge and pleaded with him to “go slow”, he politely refused to entertain their request saying that the interests of litigants were paramount to him and they should not be made to suffer for the sake of filling the pockets of lawyers.

“If all courts get a judge like him, we can bring the pendency to zero level,” the Bar Association president said.

The media-shy Murthy keeps a low-profile and has been avoiding media interviews. “He has made it clear that he does not need publicity and that he was not doing anything for records,” Reddy said when asked how the judge felt about setting a record in clearing the cases.

Murthy had earned accolades for the alacrity and speed with which he cleared cases that came up before him. He had disposed of 808 civil cases in 20 days when he was posted at Pulivendula town in Kadapa district a couple of years ago, the native place of former Chief Minister late YS Rajasekhar Reddy. The former Chief Minister commended Murthy for his work.

“Such a performance on the part of judges will restore people’s confidence in the judiciary at a time when they are scared to go to courts. They are frustrated and some of them are even taking the help of anti-social elements for parallel justice,” Reddy said.

The pro-active approach by courts would benefit litigants, a majority of whom are farmers, agricultural labourers and people from the weaker sections of society.

 
 



Learning

 6 Replies

Raj Kumar Makkad (Adv P & H High Court Chandigarh)     07 November 2010

One aspect is definitely requires to be welcome but on the other hand can one tell the quality of the judgment such judge would have given in a short working period of only 300 minutes within which such judge delievered 111 record cases. I think he could not have even properly picked all files within such short period so it is nothing but a joke to deliever good judgment after duly reading case file. Jusitce should not only be made but it should also seem to be deleivered.


(Guest)

Actually in approx. 85% cases in lower courts need not to be presented by the Advocates and at a glance of the facts come out in prima facie an intelligent & honestly dedicated judge (who do not want millage for deals otherwise) can clear these cases wasting any time for technical process.

 

By this approach people will have something in hand instead of fooling their lives around courts and advocates and have nothing but selling home for making advocates home sweet home.

 

I wish to have Advocate-Free Lower Courts and further process overall.  

 

Do something other to earn with labour other than cutting the neck of litigants treating them as chicken.

Kiran Kumar (Lawyer)     07 November 2010

well its a good effort by the judge, but it all depends upon the circumstances prevailing in a particular area.

 

in petty cases there can be a good speed but in proper cases where the entire set of evidence has to be lead and appreciated, high speed could be dangerous.

 

the number of judges is required to be increased and there shall not be too much tribunalisation of litigation.

Bhartiya No. 1 (Nationalist)     07 November 2010

Quality is certainly dougtful. Also is it valid.

Off course agrieved party will go for appeal.

Radhey (Owner)     09 November 2010

I fully support such judge and his way of passing judgement.


If a person has sharp a common sense it is not difficult to catch the central points of a case.



Other judges should learn from such a judge.


Actually advocates are the main reason for delays in court cases, litigants throw the whole burden on the advocates thinking as if the advocates are fighting cases,forgetting that it is not the advocates who fight the case, but it is the litigants who fight cases,it is only the litigants who win or lose cases.



Common people should be more law literates. Advocates may not go on lingering cases of litigants who are legally educated.



An advocate would never wish a case to be finished easily, his income would stop , if a case is finished, so better if a litigant heavy monetary benefit to his advocate on winning.Thus cases may be disposed off faster.


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register